Fellow Pinwheel Cookie lovers, I was at my local grocery store today, happened to be in the cookie aisle, and thought I'd check out the Pinwheel Cookies to see if the Nabisco/Mondelez company was still trying to pass off their "New Fudge Recipe" with the marshmallow...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

I don't know what they did to these pinwheels but I'm never buying them anymore I'm checking out other pinwheels from other companies!! yuck!!!!

5.0
I didn't like
  • New pinwheels recipe
#935765
Reply to reviews
I used to enjoy the Pinwheel cookies before some genius decided to change the cookies in order to maintain 12 per pack and make more money. Obviously it was thought that the consumer wasn't smart enough to tell the difference. So smaller cookies with a thinner...
Read more
1.0
I didn't like
  • New pinwheels
#908909
Reply to reviews
I was a raving fan of the Pinwheel cookies for over 50 years. The "new recipe" cookie tastes like cr*p on a stick. Whoever the geniuses are who think this cookie can be passed off as food should be fired in masse. No one with a brain could possibly think this would be...
Read more
Nabisco Wildwood, Missouri
#903291
Reply to reviews
The new recipe for Pinwheel cookies is a huge mistake. My wife hates the new taste as the original recipe was her favorite. She instructed me to take the package back to store for a refund. Hope enough complaints will cause Nabisco to bring back the original recipe....
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

The most recent batch of pinwheels I got were pretty tasteless. The chocolate didn't even cover the bottom and was dry. What happened? Please go back to the old recipe!!!

Anonymous
Anonymous

I was shocked to find the word "fudge" had replaced "real chocolate" on the pinwheels package. "Fudge" in my experience always means that there is not enough chocolate in the...

2.9
I liked
  • Original dark chocolate pinwheels
I didn't like
  • Poor quality and taste of new and improved pinwheels
#886130
Reply to reviews

So I haven't been able to find Pinwheels in the grocery stores for several months, maybe closer to a year. I was delighted when I saw them back in the store the other day. Finally, my favorite cookie was back! I couldn't wait to get them home and dig in. Imagine my...
Read more
I didn't like
  • Changes in pinwheel cookies
#856783
Reply to reviews
Nabisco chocolate pinwheels used to be my favorite cookie. Sometimes I would buy 5-6 packages at a time (don't judge). But now they stink! The new recipe tastes cheap (as in cheap chocolate- the old darker chocolate was much better) and what a rip- sure the package...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

I agree with you! taste is inferior. Why did they fix the best cookie? ARRGH

Allzac
Allzac

I agree one hundred percent with you! So disappointed!

2.3
I didn't like
  • Nabisco no longer seems to care about quality
  • Change in quality or recipe
  • Shrinking package for same price
#851606
Reply to reviews
I've eaten these for over 40 yrs. Yes 40 yrs. Twirls in the summer and pinwheels in the winter. To my disappointment, nabisco just changed the recipe. The chocolate tastes fake, bottom is half the size and the marshmallow is too squishy. They made the cookies smaller...
Read more
I didn't like
  • Pinwheel cookie
#822246
Reply to reviews

"FRESH LOOK NEW RECIPE STILL 12 COOKIES" Package: No Window, cannot see product at all. I almost didn't buy this package because of the 'no-window' change. The cookies melt easily so don't sell them in the summer. Contents: The fudge coating tastes cheap and sugary,...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

i agree!!!!!!!

I didn't like
  • New pinwheel cookies
#817958
Reply to reviews
I have been reading the comments regarding the "LOSS" of the well known cookie. I totally agree with the comments. The cookie has been ruined. This cookie was probably the only thing a person had in life to look forward to....and now it has been taken away. I realize...
Read more
#811440
Reply to reviews
Why did you change the old Pinwheel recipe. It's okay, but it's not what I have bought and enjoyed for probably 40 years. It was a completely unique and flavor for which I'd willingly pay double your normal price. It was a true luxury, and unmatched anywhere except...
Read more
Anonymous
Anonymous

Will never buy pinwheels again. Might as well buy some off-brand for half the price. They taste the same.... NOW!!!

Anonymous
Anonymous

I couldn't agree more. I miss the old ones, and the recipe is awful.

3.0
#793179
Reply to reviews