Skip to content
Shaw Law Firm

Shaw Law Firm

shawlawfirm.net
What is your customer experience with Shaw Law Firm?

Shaw Law Firm Overview

The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.

AI insights based on reviews
Rating Distribution

1.9 star rating from 6 reviews; consumers are mostly dissatisfied with customer service, reliability, and report a high price level. Rating distribution shows 83% unfavorable and 17% positive.

Key Takeaways for Future Customers

  • Check Shaw Law Firm reviews and weigh reported risks before hiring.
  • Ask clear questions about billing and fees up front to avoid surprise charges.
  • Confirm expected responsiveness for your case and insist on written timelines.

Negative Feedback / Risk Areas

  • Repeated complaints about poor communication and customer service.
  • Allegations of unethical conduct, privacy breaches, and unreliable representation.
  • Multiple reports of high fees, billing errors, and perceived overcharging.

Positive Feedback

Some clients report effective advocacy, timely responsiveness, and cost-conscious handling that led to favorable outcomes for their cases.

View full overview ›

Turn one complaint into a collective action

PC collective complaint

A Collective Complaint helps you unite consumers dealing with the same issue, such as wrong charges, unexpected fees, damaged items, or misleading promises. It goes beyond a single review by growing stronger with every signature, making it harder to ignore. Once you reach 20 supporters, we’ll send it to the company to encourage a response.

Start Collective Complaint
Show reviews that mention
attorney scott shaw case shaw money divorce client scott advice lawyers
Filter review
Sort by
Desirea Wry
map-marker Atlanta, Georgia

Homeless in Atlanta

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Scott Shaw did not assist.
  • - The reviewer paid $10,000, lost $250,000 and parental rights, suspects collusion with opposing attorney, and is now homeless.

Scott Shaw basically did nothing to assist me during the most important situation of my life. He waited until it was too late to tell me I wasn't going to receive any justice.

I had already given him $10,000 before he basically allowed me to get roped into the opposing attorney's plan. Now, (after the fact)... I have reason to believe they were working together. Scott Shaw caused me to lose a total of $250,000 and also lose any rights as a father.

I am now homeless.

I believe Scott Shaw became an attorney solely to rip people off.

He is a horrible man and should never be allowed to represent anyone in a court of law. You have been warned. No ethic.

No justice. No peace.

View full review
Anonymous
map-marker Atlanta, Georgia

Dont hire. No work Ethic and will not fight for his client

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Not worth the money.
  • - If you are female, go elsewhere for representation.
  • - He didn't review final paperwork and signed off on the other attorney's errors and lies.

Insulting and not worth the money. If your female, go elsewhere for representation.

No fight in him or bark unless it's at his client. Didn't even review the final paper work to find ENOMOUS mistakes & lies from the other attorney but singed off on them. Don't make the mistake my daughter did. Your money and your family are at huge risk at this guy's hands.

Insulting and not worth the money. If your female, go elsewhere for representation. No fight in him or bark unless it's at his client. Didn't even review the final paper work to find ENOMOUS mistakes & lies from the other attorney but singed off on them.

Don't make the mistake my daughter did. Your money and your family are at huge risk at this guy's hands.

Loss:
$25000
Pros:
  • Warn people
Cons:
  • Poor work ethic

Preferred solution: Full refund

View full review
1 comment
Guest

wow, I will not hire him.

Anonymous

Shaw Law Firm Attorney Review

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - They take money but don't represent you.
  • - They are slow and unprofessional.
  • - I lost thousands for no work, and I must hire a new attorney.

This firm is all about taking your money yet doesn't actually represent you. Slow!

Very unprofessional! I'm out thousands for absolutely zero work! Nothing! I was told my lawyers was working on my case...

come to find she did nothing but collect money from me!

Now I must hire a new attorney! This law group is only out to take your money not help families or fathers!

View full review
Quandarius Nex

Shaw Law Firm - Legal Services Review

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - The attorney gave questionable advice to maximize fees.
  • - High fees and unnecessary services led to extra lawyers and a private investigator.
Updated by user May 24, 2015

This attorney practices in Atlanta, Georgia- be wary!

Original review May 24, 2015

This attorney showed a most unethical way of giving advice in order to make the most money out of my daughter. We had to end up paying this guy in the end because fees were so over the top.

Gave her the worst advice which not only made her look bad to a huge in another state- but also forced her to employ two lawyers at one time and a private investigator (which she never needed in the first place and only caused a ton more trouble for her in the end!).

This attorney added on other services which were unnecessary and ended up making her look bad - and of course for which he billed for. All in all, we wish we could have done this over again- WITHOUT THIS GUY!

View full review
4 comments
Guest

Not sure who Mr. McNutt is- but this case was several years ago and your poor client most certainly did not win.

Perhaps your new client doesn't realize that you have a pretty hot temper and you tend to *** off judges- yes you do have that reputation.

I'm sure this Mr. McNutt would just love to know that you have slandered him in this public post and your client would just love to know that you have shared too much information about her and her case. Isn't it a rule that attorneys must also be conscientious of Rule 1.6, to protect a client’s confidences unless in certain instances:

(b) A lawyer may reveal information relating to the representation of a client to the extent the lawyer reasonably believes necessary:

(5) to establish a claim or defense on behalf of the lawyer in a controversy between the lawyer and the client, to establish a defense to a criminal charge or civil claim against the lawyer based upon conduct in which the client was involved, or to respond to allegations in any proceeding concerning the lawyer's representation of the client;

And wasnt' there recently a lawyer who got in trouble for revealing too much information about a client or another in a rebuttal over a negative review she had? In a recent ABA review "Lawyer accused of revealing TMI in response to bad Avvo review is reprimanded; overdraft also cited"....

and the writer goes on to write "“Lawyers should be cautious that if they choose to respond, that their response does not exceed what is necessary to respond to the review and should be mindful that they do not reveal client confidences in violation of the rule.

"

Your response here shows just how much of a good lawyer you really are. Thanks for showing us all!

Guest

Hello James McNutt. Mr.

McNutt, the author of this review, is not my client. He is the opposing party in this case. And he LOST the case. My client is ecstatic about our victory, and she most certainly did not write this review, and she adamantly told me so.

My client also reports that suspicious negative reviews have popped up, with timing just as she is in litigation with Mr. McNutt. Funny how my client, who WON the case, would think so poorly of me. When in fact, she does not.

I suggest anyone who wishes to discuss this review further contact Mr. McNutt and ask him why he is posing as someone else, and writing bad reviews about his ex-wife's attorney. I suppose if this is what he must do, I must have done my job pretty dang well.

And I don't hide behind false identities. Scott Shaw

Renaldo Cfj
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-997188

This reply does nothing to make this lawyer look any better. If this really is the owner of the business- all you did here was reveal too much information about your client and assume this is some person that your client was against in court.

This shows poor judgement on your part and as a lawyer I am surprised you would write such an elementary reply. Poor show.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-997188

DUDE- YOU WITHDREW FROM THIS CASE! YOU LEFT YOUR CLIENT HIGH AND DRY- WAS SHE THAT MUCH OF A LIABILITY TO YOU?!

YOU DIDN'T WIN ANY CASE! NOW SHE HAS TO FIND A NEW LAWYER!

View more comments (3)
Abdulrahman Akw

This guy is off the chain...

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Lawyer and PI allegedly shared private family data with multiple people, including SSNs and DOB.
  • - Sensitive data appeared in court filings and online.
Updated by user Jul 22, 2015

Oh- and dude- have you head of "The Streisand effect"? You should look it up- making threats that you are going to sue people for posting true reviews online is just going to make things worse.

Its our First Amendment right to be able to do so. You weren't defamed dude- you made a *** mistake with other people's very personal information - you made a *** of people pissed off.

Original review Jul 22, 2015

So I am sitting at home and I get an email from my father saying that some of our family and extended family's private information has been gotten by some lawyer in Atlanta... I'm like- WTF?!

I learn from my in law that this lawyer told his client to pay a private investigator to get private information on certain member of my family. He then sent it to several other people- some in another state- who then included it in court filing and without removing the social security numbers and it was online for a while for everyone to get a hold of. Scott Shaw should have known federal law requires lawyers to act in the best interest of all people when they have sensitive information like SSNs, addresses, Dates of birth, etc. in their offices.

You don't go around emailing to everyone - and then have it show up on some public internet site so that other people can pay for it! I was so pissed. Then I heard about his public statements on another review on this site blaming his client's ex for making negative reviews?! Dude- what are you smoking?!

Do you know how many people you have pissed off with your private investigation report and all their information being published online no thanks to you emailing it to everyone?! Like a million people dude! False allegations on a public review site?! That's major defamation and really bad judgement coming from a lawyer who has "years of experience".

First of all- from what we have heard AND read in ALL the court documents- (which can be uploaded to this website by the way for all to see the truth)- everything that person claims in that last review ACTUALLY HAPPENED- there is no denying that! And your claims of winning that case? From what I saw on the court documents- again they are all public record- you were never even assigned to that case! But I did hear that you have a case to be played out in Georgia and I did hear that you showed your *** in front of that judge before...

I say Good Luck with that one! And - why would you have your own client pay for a Private investigator's report that she has no justification to get in the first place when that puts her in a very precarious situation later if it is questioned? Dude- you threw her under the bus for real- you covered your *** on that one- gotta give you that much. It would have been a bit more understandable if you, a lawyer, had ordered that PI report and those Socials that it does for her to have ordered them.

Identity theft?!

I know this background check affected two large families and many exes and their children. All these people have been contacted and some filed complaints against you and that other crazy lawyer who posted all of it online in the other state. OF course- you sent it to him and you had the power to black out all the private information- but you didn't do it.

You got a *** load of people pissed at you guys thats for sure.

DON'T USE THIS GUY- IN MY OPINION, HE GIVES QUESTIONABLE ADVICE TO HIS CLIENTS AND HE DIDN'T KEEP PRIVATE PERSONAL INFORMATION ON OTHER PEOPLE PRIVATE WHEN HE HAD THE POWER AND THE KNOWLEDGE TO DO SO.

Cons:
  • How he invaded my privacy

Preferred solution: Complaints to the Bar association

View full review
3 comments
Guest

This guy has no professional ethic.

Guest

This attorney hasn't won anything! He recently withdrew from this case and has left his client high and dry....

on her own...

shows his true character for his lack of advocacy for his client... pretty sad.

Guest

Wow - this guy is totally nuts. When you launch into an attack that much over some legal thing, you know you've lost it.

Sounds like the attorney did what the attorney was supposed to do - work for his client and if you don't like it, then get an attorney to work for you. But to slam the opposing attorney for beating you . . .

pretty lame . . . just saying .

. .

View more comments (2)
Desirea Wry
map-marker Aiken, South Carolina

Short Review on May&nbs-04:00;12,&nbs-04:00;2016

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full

Scott Shaw is highly incompetent and unethical.

View full review
Castiel Qey
map-marker Newark, New Jersey

What a nightmare

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Not recommended.
  • - Invoicing shows misspellings, duplicates, and errors.
  • - Settlement info missing and the conversation is confusing.

Unhappy Divorce Client of Scott W. Shaw- Atlanta Attorney

shawlaw.com

5 Concourse Pkwy NE #3000, Atlanta, GA 30328

DO NOT RECOMMEND

Nightmare! Misspellings, duplicated billing, addition errors, makes assumptions then proceeds as if there are no options but the one he recommends; settlement agreement missing; important information for the case to be in favor of the client, confusing conversation and invoicing. He seemed smart and qualified at first, but as you learn his pattern, he is scattered, unorganized, and tells stories you pay for when you see your bill is greater than the amount of work you think he performed.

View full review
Anonymous
map-marker London, England

Shaw Law Firm - Divorce Lawyer Service Review from London, London

AI Highlights
  • - Reviewer says the service is insulting and not worth the money.
  • - Claims the lawyer favored men, didn't review final papers, and missed mistakes.

Brilliant but insulting and not worth the money. If your female, go elsewhere for representation.

He leans toward the mans side, like he's going through his own divorce all over again. No fight in him or bark unless it's at his client.

Didn't even review the final paper work to find ENOMOUS mistakes & lies from the other attorney but signed off on them. Don't make the mistake my daughter did.

View full review
Meka Hqw
map-marker Los Angeles, California

Unimpressed

AI Highlights
  • - Family member's acrimonious divorce showed he did little for them.
  • - His reply is hot tempered and unprofessional.
  • - Word has spread in our area.

Family member used this guy and interestingly enough gave me a head's up about the latest postings on this site about him. After knowing what my family member went through during their acrimonious divorce and how little it seemed he did for them (according to my cousin who went through many months of this torture)... and then reading this guy's apparent response to another review below pretty much sums it all up.

Basically- hot tempered, unprofessional, and well- his reply just says it all really. Not a good way to market your business or professionalism but from what we have heard- it didn't surprise me that much.

His reply is now all over town- at least where we are from-word travels fast in these thar parts...

View full review
Ellamae Kpj

He pushed me to get the win

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Mr. Shaw kept me focused during divorce and helped me win.
  • - He pushed me to do the leg work and was blunt but supportive.
  • - I highly recommend him.

I had to post this here, as I've already posted it on AVVO, but some whiner is out here bad-mouthing the attorney who kicked butt in my case and I just had to say something about it. Mr.

Shaw saw me at my worst, going through the worst time in my life, my divorce, yet he kept me focused on the real goals (not my overly emotional, unrealistic expectations) and pushed me to do the work it took to help him win my case. He kept telling me it was my leg work that won, but really, it was his pushing me and keeping me strong even when I wanted to cave, that got the win. In hindsight, it was the more horrible time in my life, and I thank God I had Mr. Shaw there to get me through it.

He was blunt, to the point, called me out when I was wimping out, and was my champion.

I highly recommend him. Oh, and for the wimp who is using a public place to try to cover up for his obvious loss in court with MY attorney beating him - GROW UP - YOU LOST BUDDY!

Pros:
  • Bullog attorney won in court
View full review
Anonymous
map-marker Alpharetta, Georgia

Trusted Counsel and Great Advocate

AI Highlights
  • - Other attorneys offered bland answers.
  • - Scott Shaw understood concerns, proposed strategies, and was timely, accessible, and affordable.

When my marriage entered choppy waters, I interviewed a few attorneys who all gave the same bland answers which left me hopeless about what I wanted and felt deserved to get. Then, based on reviews in this forum, I spoke with attorney Scott Shaw over the phone and then met with him at his office.

Scott impressed me immediately by not only grasping the concerns I had, but also by suggesting ideas/strategies that gave me the confidence that I had a good shot at getting the outcomes I was hoping to achieve. That was a big step forward for me. From there on, trust started building and I relied on Scott to help me out with a couple of tricky situations where I found him to be both timely/responsive and creative in coming up with excellent solutions. Throughout the case, Scott provided solid legal counsel and great friendly advice.

He was a busy attorney but was generally accessible fairly quickly, even during weekends, which translates to “peace of mind” in difficult times. Another characteristic that stood out was that he made a conscious effort to keep the legal fees low even when he could have taken advantage of my desperation at times. How often can you say that?! All said and done, Scott was a terrific attorney and a consummate professional who genuinely cared about my case and the way he provided his services.

He has my heartiest recommendation! Bravo, Scott, keep it up!

View full review

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article