Skip to content
Psychiatrist Peter Doherty

Psychiatrist Peter Doherty

www.peterdoherty.com.au
What is your customer experience with Psychiatrist Peter Doherty?

Psychiatrist Peter Doherty Overview

The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.

Based on reviews, created with AI
Rating Distribution

Psychiatrist Peter Doherty has a 1.7 star rating from 6 reviews; overall sentiment is mostly negative with a few long-term positive experiences and a high price level noted.

Key Takeaways for Future Customers

  • Psychiatrist Peter Doherty reviews show mixed clinical outcomes; some long-term patients report effective treatment for chronic suicidal depression.
  • Many complaints mention IME reports and perceived insurer bias, so check conflict of interest concerns before booking.

Negative Feedback / Risk Areas

  • Recurring customer complaints cite abrupt manner, alleged biased IME reports favoring insurance companies, and reports of poor diagnostic consistency.
  • Consumers note high price level and limited insurance plan acceptance as additional risks.

Positive Feedback

Some patients praise long-term effective medication management, compassionate outcomes for chronic depression, and helpful clinical advice.

View full overview ›

Media from reviews

Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Complaint
Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty, Psychiatrist, Richmond...Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty,... - Image 2Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty,... - Image 3Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty,... - Image 4Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty,... - Image 5
View all media ›

Turn one complaint into a collective action

PC collective complaint

A Collective Complaint helps you unite consumers dealing with the same issue, such as wrong charges, unexpected fees, damaged items, or misleading promises. It goes beyond a single review by growing stronger with every signature, making it harder to ignore. Once you reach 20 supporters, we’ll send it to the company to encourage a response.

Start Collective Complaint
Show reviews that mention
companies peter insurance doherty insurance companies inability association examination opinions repetitive
Filter review
Sort by
Amora Oll

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer
| map-marker Melbourne, Victoria

Warning to others!

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Saw him as a worksafe IME years ago.
  • - Claims Doherty writes reports to suit insurers; fraudulent paperwork; 7 months reimbursed; wishes he dies.

Saw him as a worksafe IME years ago. Doherty is another corrupt individual prepared to write whatever he is instructed to by insurance companies; he wrote multiple reports on me after seeing him once. I ended up at the medical panels and handed over the recording of him and fraudulent paperwork from the insurance company and their reports and decision were wiped, I was reimbursed for 7 months of payments after that.

KI hope Doherty dies a slow painful death after what he had done to me.

Preferred solution: He be deregistered from practicing

User's recommendation: Keep away he is corrupt!

View full review
1 comment
Guest

Hi I’ve just dodged a bullet with that one. Could you please tell me what the out come was. Thanks Dean

Sam B Trv

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Independent Medical Examination

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Alleges a vindictive October 2023 IME report benefited the insurer.
  • - Claims the report harmed health, ended treatments, and caused suicidality.
Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Independent Medical Examination
Updated by user Nov 17, 2023

I’m going to take a very strong Legal Action against the Dr Peter J Doherty.My mental state is in shambles because of his awful attitude and dishonesty and discriminatory reports.

Original review Nov 10, 2023
I have had two IME assessments arranged by the corrupt workcover agency Xchanging-DXC. Dr.

Peter J Doherty wrote a vindictive report against me in October 2023, benefiting the workcover insurer. His false reporting and failure to diagnose have had a negative impact on my physical and mental health. His actions have caused me to become suicidal and have resulted in the termination of my medical treatments and entitlements. Dr.

Doherty lacks integrity and competence, and his age and apparent inability to fulfill his duties as a medical professional and examiner are alarming. His repetitive wrong opinions, wrong diagnoses, and wrongful termination of patients are disturbing and harmful.
His close association with insurance companies and WorkSafe agencies raises concerns about potential conflicts of interest and bias in his assessments. His neglect of his duty of care for patients is deeply troubling. Dr.

Doherty's actions have contributed to a system of systemic racism and discrimination against disabled patients, which is unacceptable. I intend to take legal action against him, WorkSafe, and the relevant authorities.

If you are involved in a workcover claim, I strongly advise staying away from Dr. Doherty.

User's recommendation: I Strongly Advise staying away from Dr Peter Doherty

View full review
1 comment
Farron Zzl

Hi I was supposed to see him today under work cover but I canceled the last minute. Could you tell me what outcome was. Thanks Dean

Luigi F Mwp

Positive feedback

AI Highlights
  • - Dr Peter helped me through years of struggle and diagnosed bipolar.
  • - He recommended Lithium, and I've been on it since 2011 and well.

Dr Peter helped me when my life was an absolute roller coaster for years. He immediately diagnosed me as Bipolar and that I should be on Lithium.

First person to recommend this. I have been on this amazing compound since late 2011 and have been well.

Dr Peter is a fantastic doctor, one that I would recommend to anyone with any psychological issues. I always look forward to my appointments.

User's recommendation: Go with this man

View full review
1 comment
Farron Zzl

Hi I was supposed to see him today under work cover but I canceled the last minute. Could you tell me what outcome was. Thanks Dean

Anonymous
map-marker Rochedale, Queensland

Very Dissatisfied

AI Highlights
  • - Peter Doherty is abrupt and rude with poor people skills.
  • - The reviewer felt it was a waste of time and left worse.
  • - He did not listen.

In general this person has no people skills - he is very abrupt and rude.

From a professional point of view I found him to be a waste of time and for a person with depression I felt 10 times as bad when I left his office. During the consultation Peter Doherty did not listen to anything I had to say it was all about him and the pre meditated result in his thoughts.

Very bad experience.

- Never again. Do not go there.

View full review
1 comment
Guest

Doherty is a mouthpiece for the TAC, not the patient

Anonymous
map-marker Melbourne, Victoria

Complaint

AI Highlights
  • - Alleged Woolworths influence on a psychiatrist; report contains lies, including wine on Zoloft; no GP contact; Woolworths apologised; medical panel.
Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Complaint

This psychiatrist was hand picked by Woolworths lawyers to minimise my work place injury but the lies in his report about me left me with no choice but to report him to AHPRA

He stated that I drank three bottles of red wine per day while on 200mg of Zoloft .. why didnt he contact my gp if this was truly the case ..

medical negligent on his part already

Here I had Woolworths apologising for my psychological injury while this useless person was trying to say I was not being honest about my condition

Just a complete waste of time for the Woolworths lawyers and my lawyers .. medical panel is the next step

User's recommendation: Just read the report about you and make sure it’s true and correct .. we are fighting for justice .. the truth is everything to us

View full review
1 comment
Farron Zzl

Hi I was supposed to see him today under work cover but I canceled the last minute. Could you tell me what outcome was. Thanks Dean

Zdenka

This man is a disgrace to his profession

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Dr Peter Doherty practices in Church St, Richmond, Melbourne; diagnosed major depressive disorder in an IME.
  • - Second IME report contradicted the first.

Dr Peter Doherty who practises in Church st Richmond Melbourne. I saw this corrupt quack late last year as an IME and he diagnosed me with major depressive disorder and then wrote a second report totally contradicting his first report and making personal insults against me without even seeing me a second time. I’m sure he did this to try and destroy my work cover claim.He is a hired gun for insurance companies

Reason of review:
I am disgusted by his behaviour

Preferred solution: Stop practicing

View full review
6 comments
Farron Zzl

Hi I was supposed to see him today under work cover but I canceled the last minute. Could you tell me what outcome was. Thanks Dean

Aubreana Gnx

So true! same thing happened to me

Zdenka
reply icon Replying to comment of Aubreana Gnx

I’m so angry this *** is allowed to get away with what he’s doing. I put in a complaint against him with Ahpra but they did nothing and he got away with it. Even tried contacting the media but neither were they interested

Marisella Sxi
reply icon Replying to comment of Zdenka

Same experience.... just so worn out...

and l was ill that year after the ime's Class action .?

Seeing a case on google search of Dr and legal and the Victoria county court and Dr name in....upset me so so much even after 4-5yrs later in tears like a baby at just the same words used... Read for yourselves but PLEASE make sure you have someone with you to support you...

Farron Zzl
reply icon Replying to comment of Aubreana Gnx

Hi I was supposed to see him today under work cover but I canceled the last minute. Could you tell me what outcome was. Thanks Dean

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Farron Zzl

He is as corrupt as they come A gun for the insurance companies He changed his initial report which supported my mental health condition to “She’s making it all up as she goes” He changed the report under pressure from the insurance company He is an absolute disgrace as a psychiatrist and human being

View more comments (5)
Anonymous
map-marker Sydney, New South Wales

Liar and Fraud

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - The reviewer claims fraud by an IME and that they’re a Gallagher Bassett hired gun.
  • - They say the person writes 'utter crap' and is in it for the money.

Dont see this fraud for an IME. He is another of Gallaghar Bassett Hired guns.

He is only in it for the money that he gets paid to write utter crap. Absolute disgrace. And they wonder why people have mental issues. STAY AWAY from this low life.

There needs to be a royal commission into this sort of behaviour.

URGENTLY. Mental health issues shouldnt be treated the way these hired guns go about things!!!

View full review
3 comments
Farron Zzl

Hi I was supposed to see him today under work cover but I canceled the last minute. Could you tell me what outcome was. Thanks Dean

Aubreana Gnx

Also used by Allianz! He should lose his licence! If you get this Dr for your IME ask for a different DR.

Farron Zzl
reply icon Replying to comment of Aubreana Gnx

Hi I was supposed to see him today under work cover but I canceled the last minute. Could you tell me what outcome was. Thanks Dean

View more comments (2)
Spencer M Ihe

The New York Appellate Court Ethics Committee disagrees with Dr Doherty

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Dr Peter Doherty claims to be a legal expert.
  • - The NY Disciplinary Committee disbarred Mastercard's lawyer Keila Ravelo using Doherty's sting.

Dr Peter Doherty from Monash University claims to be an expert in legal matters, however the New York Supreme Court's Disciplinary Committee disbarred Mastercard's lawyer, Ms Keila Ravelo, with the help of the facts that Dr Doherty divulged in a sting. Dr Doherty's report is with the chief of the US Prosecution's national security division, Ms Eileen Decker whose experience includes the arrests of the Malaysian Prime Minister, and he disagrees with the SEC Prosecutor of Gotti.

Doherty did exactly as the whistleblowers in McGarvie's office said he would. Antipedophile advocate Fiona Bennett knew what his report said. ActivistNews Australia knew what his report said said at the moment McGarvie received it. Rural Action Group knew.

Anti-corruption advocates knew. Elliot Sgargetta was tipped off and It All Came True, he reported to the FBI. As well as the disbarment of Mastercard's lawyer, the Victorian Supreme Court disbarred the tax avoiding gambling barrister Stirling and next is his mate Mctaggart and Hibbert and Hodges. If you ever intend to see Dr Doherty, send in an undercover agent.

I was on A Current Affair and they send in fake patients to dodgy doctors.

Ask them for an actor and wait to see Dr Doherty blow the whistle and try to find out what his paying insurers want him to do. Cheerio, Whistleblowers Fight Back.

Pros:
  • New york disbarred keila ravelo
Cons:
  • Drpeter
Reason of review:
Poor customer service

Preferred solution: Full refund

View full review
Anonymous

Magician

AI Highlights
  • - Cool, down-to-earth demeanor; he cuts to the core.
  • - Harsh at times, but his method touches deep wounds; he is no longer practising.

I liked him. Thought he was cool!

Pity he is no longer practising. Admittedly I felt like 'lamb sent to slaughter'- relative to his seemingly harsh methods; however in one hour he was able to touch on wounds that were hidden....perhaps even from myself. So deeply embedded that, evidently, over a decade of talking with different so called 'professionals' was clearly a waste. I don't mind his cool demeanour and seeming lack of empathy.

He cuts to the core! As swiftly and sharp his 'blows' did feel, I was inspired by the ability to feel anything at all. Impressive. I snapped at him for probing me too far.

I found some questions inappropriate and irrelevant. He didn't seem to mind my reaction. He can take it! Speak your mind with him freely.

Don't be intimidated, he's down to earth and not that scary. Also do not lie to him. He is a walking lie detector. I trust he is a magician for that alone.

For those of you whom have gone out of your way to afford us all the horrifying reviews I discovered after our meeting; I can understand how Dr. Doherty's methods might seem brutal.... to which I say, too harsh! Collectively he was slandered to such that I was disturbed having read all that.

Glad I did not read it before attending. Cut the man a break, he deals with liars and insane people most frequently. What a *** job, not to mention the parasitic insurance companies. He's not that bad.

I went alone. His office was lovely. Stunning Feng shui with lot's of sunlight. Tasteful decore- ambient!

Immaculate and peaceful. Surroundings are a reflections of what resides within. I love my feng shui. His office was even in the abundance corner.

Was comfortable. His reception staff positively lovely. Stunning pot plants all over the place. Everything clean and tidy.

A kind greeting by him, was told I could sit anywhere. I was invited to address him by his first name, suggesting to me immediately he is not afflicted with the 'God Complex'... My appointment was lucky last and he was nice enough to me. I imagine the tail end of anyone's work day would be tiresome.

Fancy how exhausted he must have been, listening to people offload on him all day for IME reports. How tedious and boring! I am no genius but I believe Peter to be highly highly intelligent and am doubtful he would suffer fools with the tolerance of an average mind. This does not make him a monster in my view.

In him I was able to detect a harsh yet experienced critic YES indeed.... but also a father... and he was impartial. It was disappointing that Peter is no longer practising, I would have liked a session with him later down the track.

something told me he would make a better Dr. than report writer. I don't believe he is guilty of anything but being good at his job. People can be too quick to judge especially if triggered.

Myself included. If you are a weak person, perhaps take a friend. This man may not be for the faint hearted.

If you are independent and resilient with nothing of relevance to hide then you have nothing to worry about. Hope this helps

Reason of review:
Good customer service
View full review
3 comments
Guest

The Ombudsman's email on her file C 15 1**** clearly says they thought there was so much corrupt conduct that the case should be examined by anti corruption experts. Eileen Decker was a director of US national security cases like the one she prosecuted the CBA's Keith Hunter for after Dr Doherty went ahead with what the staff said they wanted no part of.

Guest

He really does pluck things out of the air

Guest

If he's not practising why does his office say he does?

View more comments (2)
Jorene Mtu

Excellent help for many years for chronic suicidal depression.

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - I've seen Peter Doherty for 10+ years, his manner was hard.
  • - Second opinion matched his method.
  • - I'm happy; my partner attends and I decide.

I've been seeing Peter Doherty for over 10 years. I had problems getting in tune with his manner and after about 12-18 months I sought a second opinion from a psychiatrist I sourced independently.

I was seriously considering shifting away from Doherty. Doherty raised no qualms about sending my record to this other psychiatrist. However, the second psychiatrist, who really impressed me, impressed upon me the reality Peter's treatment of me was no different to what he (the 2nd psych., would employ. I decided to continue with Peter and have mostly been very happy since.

I've adapted better to his manner, which I've always found to be kind, but apparently a bit offhand. I've always found his advice to be good (I research everything thoroughly), he has always given me plenty of choice, ALL drug increase, change, and decrease decisions are mine, based, of course on the knowledge he imparts. He clearly sets out the options, and the pros and cons of each. Since the 2nd opinion I've always taken my partner with me.

He's never questioned that, and realises it helps in the sense that she is able to give him better input on my condition and any changes than I can, and she is able both to add to my recall (I have an appalling memory, made worse by one of my drugs) and to help me at times better interpret what I've been told. This has helped me considerably. Would I recommend Peter Doherty to others? Yes, but with provisos.

And I would stress that if any prospective patient finds him difficult at first, if they can cope it would be good to bear with him. The time taken is, I believe, well worth it.

Pros:
  • Treatment for clincical chronic suicidal depression
Cons:
  • Peters attitude initially but i now have full confidence
Reason of review:
Good customer service
View full review
4 comments
Guest

If he hasn't cured you in 10 years, how much have you paid him?

Guest

Is his opinion dependent on who pays his bill?

Guest

I wish to make an addition in my own words... Peter is not a *** head!

Guest

Thanks for the insight... Yes that resonates with me.

I have a ind of my own I like to believe and this review is honest I feel. Thank you.

View more comments (3)
Breah Pce
map-marker North Holland, Netherlands

Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty, Psychiatrist, Richmond Victoria

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Dr Doherty of Richmond, Melbourne, isn't the Nobel Prize winner.
  • - He thinks world is chocolate and roses.
  • - Law enforcement and banking avoid him.
Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty, Psychiatrist, Richmond...
Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty,... - Image 2
Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty,... - Image 3
Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty,... - Image 4
Psychiatrist Peter Doherty - Associate Professor Dr Peter Doherty,... - Image 5

Dr Doherty of Richmond Melbourne Australia is not be confused with the Nobel Prize winner by the same name.

The man is delusional if he thinks the world is chocolate and roses.

Anyone in law enforcement, white collar or organized crime or banking should avoid him unless they want their feelings hurt.

He doesn't believe in undercover operations, whistleblowers, the FBI joint task forces, or Royal Commissions. He will disregard anything that gets in the way of whoever is paying him in my opinion.

Cons:
  • Leaks
Reason of review:
Damaged or defective

Preferred solution: Price reduction

View full review
4 comments
Guest

Sidney, the County Court jailed Bill Jordanou's ponzi scam as reported in Cameron's article in the Age.

Guest

Your review am sorry makes you seem like an imbecile. Not that I am not objective but that's so wrong.

Guest

The American FBI was furious when he tried to find out what they knew from Whistleblowers like me. I want $1,000,000 compensation from him.

Guest

At least a dozen victims say that "VCAT" can review Dr. Peter Doherty under the "Health Records Act".

View more comments (3)

Hospitals, Clinics and Medical Centers Expert Talks

4th COVID Vaccine, Monkeypox, Mask-Optional Policy

4th COVID Vaccine, Monkeypox, Mask-Optional Policy

COVID, monkeypox, mask-optional policy: Are we safe? Watch an expert interview with Prof. Karen Jubanyik from Yale to learn more about viruses and how to stay protected.

Prof. Karen Jubanyik
Prof. Karen Jubanyik

Karen Jubanyik, MD is Associate Professor, Clinician-Educator Track, in the Department of Emergency Medicine at Yale University School of Medicine.

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article