Jenny D Thr

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Horrible place to live

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full

We moved in a dirty outdated apartment with broken things all thru the apartment. The maintenence and office staff are greedy and dishonest.

We moved out after 10 years of faithful payment of rent.

We cleaned everything. They charged us for things they never fixed and for not cleaning.

View full review
  • Near the hospital you will need it because you will get sick

Preferred solution: Apology

map-marker Newark City, Ohio

Too unsafe

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full

have to call city and county departments to have safety lighting fixed, sidewalks fixed (one slab rocks and if s.o. falls fingers could be pinched/cut off), address 20 year old stove and three broken or missing smoke alarms.

never mind all of the broken electrical stuff that violates code.

since management allowed for a drug house to flourish, and guns, violence and drug traffic and stolen cars allowed to be dropped off in one unlit parking lot...they have had more than enough time to prove they are here for themselves and do not care about the safety of our neighborhood. only.their friends and associates with guns, drugs, and who are violent. read the police reports, it is all there.

the pool still sits empty and will not be fixed because it will cost.too much to make it safe. we pay near a grand each unit, but we have no safety, buldings are rotting....this is criminal.



View full review
map-marker Newark, Ohio

Horrible Management

The new management in mcmillan woods is HORRIBLE. If you complain about parking they tow YOU.

The hold rent payments until mid month then if there is an issue they refuse payment unless Rent + $105 in fees is paid by cashier check . They refused I went in with cashiers check for my rent and they refused stating that it is past the grace period. This was due to them refusing contact for a week then refusing my rent by cashiers check. it was past the grace period because they refused contact and refused payment!

They extort their residents and if you complain about anything they just make the problem worse. I do NOT recommend living here and do so at your own risk. I have NEVER been late on my rent period in 2.5 years.

I am a disabled veteran on fixed income as well as a long time resident thru 3 different property management/managers in that time. Keep up your search!

View full review
  • Spacious apartments
  • Inconsiderate management
  • Exterior of apartments have been degrading withou
  • Managment
Reason of review:
Problems with payment

Preferred solution: Price reduction

map-marker Newark, Ohio

Bathroom Shower

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full

Our bathroom in the shower I couldn't leave any shower stuff because it would freeze. I spoke with Shelia and she said it would take three days to fix it which would be Monday Tuesday and Wednesday.

They started on it Monday and are not done yet. I also told Shelia that I was to be told when they were coming in our apartment and if they couldn't make it to call and let me know and I absolutely do not want them in unless they call me and ask. We will have lived at McMillan almost a year and they are just getting started on a lot of the problems. Because hoping to get more of their apartments rented out.

Preferably to college kids.

Then if you decide to go Month too month after your lease is up McMillan Woods charges you an extra $100 a month. Ridiculous.

View full review
Reason of review:
Not as described/ advertised
1 comment

yes, one maintenance guy went in to an apartment found the beer in the fridge and got drunk and fell asleep on the couch. the tenant returned home from work and found him passed out on couch.

the semi annual inspections take a minute if you are there. but if you are not they can take up to a half hour going through your stuff.

one friend woke up to find them ruffling through her stuff. another watches them on inspection days in the apartments around them.

map-marker Toronto, Ohio

Parking spots

So when we did our application we had THREE adults on the lease. As we are signing the lease and getting to to the car/parking part they release we had three cars.

He kept his car at his moms apartment since she only has one car. Well it's becoming winter time and there is no way my husband can walk in the snow and rain to Davita which isn't far from our apartment. We pay to live their $820 to be exact and I think it's bull *** that YOU people tell us where we can and can't park. Then turn around and tow peoples cars.

I think if the office people had to park on Terrace Ave everyday and walk to the office then they might think twice about it. I will not recommend this apt. to anyone.

and to top it off before we turned all our paperwork in for the application you guys called EVERYDAY and then a lady and man were both RUDE to me. We had a hard time getting paperwork done when our brother was fighting cancer and I worked nights and my sister worked days.

View full review

this place has even upset the towing companies. not one around will tow for them anymore.

when a druggie car blocked mine and i had to call to have it towed i learned this. SO PARK AWAY WHEREVER YOUR HEART DESIRES.


Same issue here. I complained about the parking here at mcmillan woods and they towed MY car because I had to park in someone else's because someone parked in mine.

Cost $120, not waivable. I recommend people just skip over this place and keep up your search.

View more comments (1)
daniellenichole L
map-marker Columbus, Ohio

McMillen Woods Terrible Place to Live!!

Mcmillen woods made me pay a huge deposit of over 800$ and then turned around and said i dont get it back and in addition owe them 633$!!! For damages and breaking a lease.

Which is *** because i gave them over a 30 day notice both written and verbal and yet they claim they never got it. Which is also funny is i took pictures of before we moved in and the condition it was in afterwards and theres no way that normal wear and tear cost over 1400$.

So therefore i will be suing! I just dont want to see anyone else taking advantage of!!!!!

View full review

Real Estate Expert Talks

What Do Property Management Companies Do @ Interview with Property Management Expert

Nov 27, 2020

Colby Hager, a a real estate investor and home remodeling expert, talks about property management companies, what they are, and how to choose the right property management company.

Read full article
Colby Hager
Colby Hager

Colby Hager is an experienced real estate investor with Capstone Homebuyers. He has years of experience in renovating houses, home remodeling, and property management.

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article