Skip to content
Lancaster Archery Supply

Lancaster Archery Supply

lancasterarchery.com
What is your customer experience with Lancaster Archery Supply?

Lancaster Archery Supply Overview

The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.

Based on reviews, created with AI
Rating Distribution

2.4 star rating based on 1 review; consumers are mostly dissatisfied with a 100% unfavorable rating distribution.

Positive Feedback

If an item is in stock and requires no assembly or custom work, customers report acceptable orders and on-shelf availability.

Negative Feedback / Risk Areas

  • Damaged goods shipped and poor quality control on assembled items.
  • Subpar custom services such as arrow cutting and insert work leading to returns.
  • Time lost processing returns and pursuing refunds through customer service.
  • Packed items used as shipping material causing further product damage.

Key Takeaways for Future Customers

  • Check Lancaster Archery Supply reviews and recent customer complaints before ordering custom work.
  • Avoid assembly or cut-and-insert services; buy stocked, pre-packaged items when possible.
  • Be prepared to request refunds and contact customer service if items arrive damaged.
View full overview ›

Media from reviews

Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems.
Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems. - Image 2Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems. - Image 3Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems. - Image 4Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems. - Image 5
View all media ›

Turn one complaint into a collective action

PC collective complaint

A Collective Complaint helps you unite consumers dealing with the same issue, such as wrong charges, unexpected fees, damaged items, or misleading promises. It goes beyond a single review by growing stronger with every signature, making it harder to ignore. Once you reach 20 supporters, we’ll send it to the company to encourage a response.

Start Collective Complaint
Resolved
robert k Jaf

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer
| map-marker East Lampeter, Pennsylvania

Resolved: Big order, big problems.

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Six Easton FMJ 300 arrows arrived; five had warped fletching.
  • - Broadhead threads were deep; blades wiggle when tightened.
  • - Case was used to ship arrows.
Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems.
Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems. - Image 2
Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems. - Image 3
Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems. - Image 4
Lancaster Archery Supply - Big order, big problems. - Image 5
Updated by user Jun 06, 2025

waiting for a response from customer service, but this was handled so poorly I'm returning the entire order. even he things that were ok.

Original review Jun 06, 2025
Got a 6 pack of Easton FMJ 300 spine arrows with the cut and insert service. 5 came with warped fletching all curled up.

And one of those, when they were cutting to length, missed and then cut it to the right length just above the gash they cut in the metal down to the carbon layer. I had to keep inspecting, so I got a field point and a broadhead to screw on. Well, the threads are so deep, I'd say 1/2 an inch, that on some, I could only get 2 or 3 threads to attach. And on 2, it was deep enough to not reach at all.

I mean, the fletching looked like the arrows had been stored under a mattress. Along with this order, I got a 33' Easton arrow case. Well, they unpackaged that and used it to ship these arrows. And yes, I checked the case; it comes packaged.

Then I opened the Hornet broadheads. They were tightened down like a vice, yet the blades wiggled on them. Looked it up. No, broadheads aren't supposed to wiggle.

I was looking for something on fixing the arrows, but as this was a large order and the craftsmanship on my arrow sizing and the condition of the arrows was damaged goods, I feel like they sold me their trash. So at this point, I have packed the entire order back in its box and will return it in its entirety. Surely they could have taken a look at what they were trying to send me and sent a message that what I ordered looked really bad; please pick something else.

But no, they just sent it out. This will be my last order with Lancaster.
Pros:
  • If its in stock and they dont have to assemble it youre ok
Cons:
  • Custom services are sub par
  • Wasting my time having to sent it back
  • Willingness to ship damaged goods

Preferred solution: Full refund

User's recommendation: if they have something in stock that they have no hand in making or doing work on, fine. but if they assemble anything go somewhere else.

View full review

Companies Similar to Lancaster Archery Supply

Apex Hunting reviews and complaints

Apex Hunting

0 Reviews
Merlin Archery reviews and complaints

Merlin Archery

0 Reviews
huntersfriend reviews and complaints

huntersfriend

0 Reviews
Hoyt Archery reviews and complaints

Hoyt Archery

0 Reviews

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article