Skip to content
House Sitters America

House Sitters America Reviews

www.housesittersamerica.com
What is your customer experience with House Sitters America?

House Sitters America Overview

The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.

AI insights based on reviews
Rating Distribution

2.9 star rating from 9 reviews, overall neutral sentiment with mixed experiences ranging from excellent stays to serious losses and disputes.

Key Takeaways for Future Customers

  • Check profiles carefully and vet sitters directly; this summary reflects common House Sitters America reviews urging caution.
  • Use clear written agreements and backups before relying on unpaid sitters from a free membership-style service.

Negative Feedback / Risk Areas

  • Repeated reports of theft, damage, no-shows, and inability to post negative feedback indicating House Sitters America customer complaints about accountability.
  • Poor communication and slow responses with customer service and issues around billing or refunds in some cases.

Positive Feedback

Users praise the attractive website, free service model, successful sits with good matches, and occasional prompt resolution of erroneous charges.

View full overview ›

Media from reviews

House Sitters America - Excellent service from home/pet-owner's perspective
House Sitters America - Harassment and Advocating for Unsuitable ClientsHouse Sitters America - AVOIDHouse Sitters America - AVOID - Image 2House Sitters America - AVOID - Image 3House Sitters America - AVOID - Image 4House Sitters America - AVOID - Image 5
View all media ›

Turn one complaint into a collective action

PC collective complaint

A Collective Complaint helps you unite consumers dealing with the same issue, such as wrong charges, unexpected fees, damaged items, or misleading promises. It goes beyond a single review by growing stronger with every signature, making it harder to ignore. Once you reach 20 supporters, we’ll send it to the company to encourage a response.

Start Collective Complaint
Show reviews that mention
sitter house house sitters home experience people service site profile reviews
Filter review
Sort by
Susan W Sut

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Excellent service from home/pet-owner's perspective

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - We invited unpaid sitters and contacted them through the site, exchanging numbers.
  • - We vetted by email, phone, video and references; everyone was happy.
House Sitters America - Excellent service from home/pet-owner's perspective

We've used the service a few times, inviting sitters (unpaid) to stay in our home with our dogs. We contacted potential sitters on the website, and we were able to communicate with full transparency, exchanging phone & email addresses and links.

We did our own vetting of house sitters via email, phone, and video calls, and we contacted references as well. Everyone was happy all around.

The sitters enjoyed a free stay in a desirable location, and we had peace of mind knowing all was well at the house. Zero complaints from us, but I do advise people using the service to use judgment and common sense in setting up with a house sitter.

Pros:
  • Free service
  • Good web site
Cons:
  • Requires thorough advance planning and open communication

Preferred solution: Nothing, just posting a positive review.

User's recommendation: Use common sense and advance planning

View full review
Emiy S

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

Harassment and Advocating for Unsuitable Clients

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Thomas sent resume, credit score, and reviews aggressively without a chance to talk.
  • - I was investigated and suspended for being rude.
House Sitters America - Harassment and Advocating for Unsuitable Clients

I was bombarded with information from a potential house sitter, named "Thomas", who just overwhelmingly sent me his resume, credit score, reviews (which were obviously made up) without even a chance for me to talk to him first. It was just too aggressive, so I told him "I think you oversold yourself" and I was investigated and suspended after they determined I had been rude and uncooperative. foudn I was "rude" to him.

Pros:
  • Attractiveness of websites
  • Wide range of candidates
Cons:
  • Unqualified in conflict resolution
  • Lack of telephonic communication

Preferred solution: Apology

User's recommendation: Be cautious how you tell someone why you didn't pick them

View full review
1 comment
Kymber Muy

You can’t be serious. That almost says Red Flag to me.

Featured
Violeta H Qoh

AVOID

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Arrived 2 days late, ill, refused to shadow care.
  • - Cat went missing; home damaged; belongings moved.
  • - Warning issued by the agency.
House Sitters America - AVOID
Explore video interviews
Updated by user Dec 17, 2019

The pictures provided were just a random sample of what we took.

Original review Dec 17, 2019
Extremely pissed off about how House Sitters of America took our complaint. Cid Rode as she calls herself, arrived 2 days late from what was agreed before our leaving for vacation, when she arrived late night she claimed had a bad headache and needed sleep.
Next morning and during the whole day she sequestered herself claiming she was ill, when we offered to take her to the clinic and get meds she refused.

The night before our leaving we had to drag her out of the room to move her car and to listen to what was needed from her to do while we were on vacation. She moved her car, asked us if we had the manual written, we told her we had and were waiting for her the past two days to shadow us to care for our pets and house, she didn't want to listen to anything, asked us to leave the manual available so she could go back to bed. Next morning before we left, we woke her up, told her we have been waiting with our neighbors so they could meet her and help her if she needed, she said she was still feeling sick so she needed to go and for us not to worry.
(She had never cared for fish, cats and birds) and that is what we have here. Needless to say it was a nightmare trying to get her to answer texts.

She left 2 days before we arrived, find out she lost one of our cats, she trashed our home, missing items that didn't make sense were gone, our neighbors told us they found our cat and brought it home and she was not available. Our Pets were not cared for, our entire house was in complete disarray!, furniture moved, items moved from one floor to another, wine and vodka bottles were found, (we do not drink), new top stove placed 2 days before she arrived was stained and badly scratched, red salsa was spilled from our fridge to the counters to the cabinets to the floor, bathrooms were trashed, dirty gloves with black hair dye were found in one bathroom floor staining it and black dye was spilled onto our clear oak trim staining it forever, same with our new comforter, as she took the liberty to use our bedroom, the red comforter was splatter with all sizes of black spots, ruining completely and if all these is not enough, she made sure she snooped through every closet, cabinet, container down to the smallest trinket box and was obvious about it. She even opened and inoperable over that was wired shut! breaking the wire in the process, ripped the optical cable out of the back of the TV.

This woman is a monster!. All we wanted from the House Sitters of America was to remove her from their system so nobody else had to go through this, but is has been a wasted of time.
Two weeks later due to damage she had created that we were not aware of, our living room ceiling collapsed. After much back and forth with House Sitters of America they finally decided to put 'an official warning in her file' and if they had another complaint they will remove her from their service.
Now we noticed she has updated her profile to include experience with cats, fish and birds. By the way the picture she has there must be an old one because when you look at her you would not want her in your home, but for us it was too late.

She came as blond and she obviously left a brunette (as per her hair dye she left all over our bathroom and bathroom shower). She then had the audacity to contact us, the first time via email, demanding a 100 percent positive endorsement and using a veiled threat she would report us for animal neglect. (The only neglect we have ever had was leaving them with this monster!), the second time on Dec 13 2019, via certified letter.

This time she was demanding our negative report to House Sitters of America to be removed and to give her 100 percent positive endorsement or she would sue us for defamation of character. House Sitters of America response to all these, they stick by their "warning in her file" (where nobody else can see) and 'they are sorry we are having this issue'.
So Be Aware that this Free Service can cost you thousands as it has done us !.
Loss:
$3000
Cons:
  • No accountability
  • No proper background checks
  • No way of knowing who you are getting
Reason of review:
You do Not verify your people

Preferred solution: Restitution, Reviews Enabled, Remove 'Cid Rode'

View full review
9 comments
Kymber Muy

Omg…as a pet sitter that was considering using this service, maybe I should stay away. I’m so sorry, this happened to you. We are not all cut from the same cloth.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Kymber Muy

Since this was 4 years ago I don’t remember why I’m getting these notifications. But just an FYI, they sued my mom (Cid) in small claims in Illinois and lost because they couldn’t prove that it was my mom who caused damages, and not that the damage was already there. Don’t believe all reviews you read on the internet.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-2547687

Actually to correct myself I think it was something about harassment. But anyways, take everything with a grain of salt on the internet

Keola Mfk

Yikes

Guest

So what is your final outcome? Did you get compensation for the damages done?

or did you file a criminal complaint? When you had issues with her behavior prior to departure, why did you leave her to take care of your home & pets.

Allyn Ite
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1852490

The outcome was that I Threaten them with defamation of character suit because all these awful things they were saying about me. So they sued me for harassment.

I did go to Illinois and fight the case and they did accuse me of most of the things this post. But they lost because it wasn’t true and therefore they couldn’t prove it

Guest

How horrible! I am so sorry for your horrific experience with Cid Rode!

I am disgusted that people like this ruin things for everyone else. I have been a sitter for about a year full-time and have had the best experiences and my clients will attest that I always leave the house in excellent condition and had taken excellent care of their pets.

Allyn Ite
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1836191

So what I did is threaten them with defamation of character because they were saying these awful untrue things about me. They decided to sue me for harassment and damaging their home.

And they have absolutely no proof because it wasn’t true. I went to Illinois to fight the case. They lost because they had absolutely no proof of these monsters things they said I did. Because I didn’t do them.

I work as a house sitter pet sitter for a living. And you actually believed all this terrible stuff that I did to someone and didn’t get arrested?

Netta Coh
reply icon Replying to comment of Allyn Ite

Actually all we did was request a restraining order and the judge did not grant it unless she continued to make contact or threats.. Which she now has...

View more comments (8)
Rebecca A Faf

TERRIBLE HOUSESITTER PATRICIA O'FLYNN

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Patricia O'Flynn allegedly stole money and jewelry.
  • - They will never trust this place again.
  • - Dog was distressed; they say the computer was touched.

PATRICIA O'FLYNN STOLE FROM US, SHE STOLE MONEY AND JEWELERY AND OTHER THINGS. I WILL NEVER TRUST THIS PLACE EVER AGAIN.

SHE LEFT A LOT OF *** ON OUR COMPUTER WHICH SHE SHOULD NOT HAVE TOUCHED AND OUR POOR DOG MUST HAVE BEEN TREATED SO BADLY HE WAS STILL SHAKING A WEEK AFTER WE GOT HOME.

SHE IS ONE SICK INDIVIDUAL. DO NOT USE THIS PLACE YOU MIGHT GET THIS SICKO.

Loss:
$3000
Pros:
  • Hire thieves
Cons:
  • Hire thieves

Preferred solution: IF YOU HAVE THIS THIEF STILL ON YOUR BOOKS GET RID OF HER, THESE INCIDENTS HAPPENED TO MY FRIEND WHO USED YOUR SERVICES FROM THIS THIEF. DO NOT BOTHER PHONE OR EMAIL. REVIEWS ARE GOING ALL OVER THE WEB.

User's recommendation: DONT LET PATRICIA O'FLYNN NEAR YOUR HOUSE OR PETS.

View full review
Darthvagrant W

Refund of erroneous charge.

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - A spurious charge was made to my account under another name.
  • - Credit was issued after correspondence with real people; the issue was resolved.

A spurious charge was made to my account, under another name and address (other than my own). House Sitters America ultimately and courteously issued a credit for this charge. Correspondence with real people, a satisfactory resolution of a real problem.

User's recommendation: This company can apparently be trusted.

View full review
Ron W Hsf

Exemplary response to a problem.

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - An erroneous charge was reversed by House Keepers after a brief email exchange, and the response was forthcoming and courteous in June 2020.

An erroneous charge to my account was just reversed by House Keepers after a brief E-mail exchange. It is refreshing to encounter such forthcoming, courteous response to correcting such a problem. June, 2020

Pros:
  • Prompt
  • Honest response to a problem

Preferred solution: Nothing required

View full review
Anonymous
map-marker Colorado Springs, Colorado

Awful Sitter Experience

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Sitter prioritized vacationing over pet care and stopped communicating.
  • - She accused me of theft and my dog of fleas despite vet care; dog lost weight.

Pet sitter, after several phone calls to clarify expectations, was more interested in vacationing than pet sitting. Sitter accused me of stealing something of hers as I left my home, she accused my dog of having fleas though she had just been to the vet and groomer and is on flea preventative, and worst of all stopped communication with me for five days.

I had no idea how my dog was doing until I had a friend call and speak with the sitter. My dog lost weight and house was not left as the sitter found it. I have never left a bad review for any business before, but I don’t want another person to go through what I did.

Housesitters of America would not let me leave a bad review for this particular sitter. They only accept endorsements.

Reason of review:
Bad quality
View full review
2 comments
Kymber Muy

Wow…As a pet/house sitter I am mortified. They should allow bad reviews and terminate sitters like that. I’m so sorry.

Guest

Extremely pissed off about how House Sitters of America took our complaint. Cid Rode as she calls herself, arrived 2 days late from what was agreed before our leaving for vacation, when she arrived late night she claimed had a bad headache and needed sleep.

Next morning and during the whole day she sequestered herself claiming she was ill, when we offered to take her to the clinic and get meds she refused. The night before our leaving we had to drag her out of the room to move her car and to listen to what was needed from her to do while on vacation. She moved her car, asked us if we had the manual written, we told her we had and were waiting for her the past two days to shadow us to care for our pets and house, she didn't want to listen to anything, asked us to leave the manual available so she could go back to bed. Next morning before we left, we woke her up, told her we have been waiting with our neighbors so they could meet her and help her if she needed, she said she was still feeling sick so she needed to go and for us not to worry.

(She had never cared for fish, cats and birds) and that is what we have here. Needless to say it was a nightmare trying to get her to answer texts. She left 2 days before we arrived, find out she lost one of our cats, she trashed our home, missing items that didn't make sense were gone, our neighbors told us they found our cat and brought it home and she was not available. Our Pets were not cared for, our entire house was in complete disarray!, furniture moved, items moved from one flor to another, wine and vodka bottles were found, (we do not drink), new top stove placed 2 days before she arrived was stained and badly scratched, red salsa was spilled from our fridge to the counters to the cabinets to the floor, bathrooms were trashed, dirty gloves with black dye were found in one bathroom floor staining it and black dye was spilled onto our clear oak trim staining it forever.

Two weeks later due to damage she had created that we were not aware of our living room ceiling collapsed. After much back and forth with House Sitters of America they finally decided to put 'an official warning in her file' and if they had another complaint they will remove her from their service.

Now we noticed she has updated her profile to include experience with cats, fish and birds. By the way the picture she has there must be an old one because when you look at her you would not want her in your home, but for us it was too late.

View more comments (1)
Anonymous
map-marker Plymouth, Minnesota

I suggested my daughter who is an experienced pet sittered sign up to be a sitter she paid fee

She applied to 3 homes and never got a reply. Is this company a total SCAM?

View full review
Jayre M

The most amazing vacation

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - They question a negative prompt about reporting.
  • - They had a great time and made new friends.
  • - They still email and will meet again soon.

Why does this site have a negative prompt asking me if I reported my experience back to the Housesitter people? We all had a great time, housesitters, owners, pets.

We all made new friends.

This was a few years ago however we still email. We will also get together in a few weeks.

Reason of review:
Good quality
View full review
1 comment
Susan W Sut

We've had a similar experience--good care, good experience, new friends. We planned far in advance and did our own vetting of sitters. So far it's been great.

doggylover

No way to let others know about bad sitters.

AI Highlights
  • - Many sitter responses; profiles were reviewed.
  • - Some profiles lied or were unreliable, and some asked for money.
  • - We went with a neighbor's friend.

We needed a sitter and we had so many responses from sitters right away, exchanged emails, met in person, etc. There is no way to warn others about these sitters. They know our address, and who knows what psycho and those who has nothing to lose can do to us.

We carefully went though their profiles and started to contact persons who we thought was best match.

They were liers and simply homeless and/or has huge debts needing money. One guy had great profile, good response until we started asking questions which he had to reveal the truth. He was a psycho. Other guy was super nice when we met in person, but as soon as he found out he cant get what he wanted, he revealed true himself. He thinks dog outside in 100 degree is not an issue. One guy's age on profile was a huge lie (30 yo was mid 40's). One lady just simply cancelled on the day SHE WANTED to meet us. Some people ask for money. Some people said they have great references and committed to do the house sit, until we actually asked for the references.

The whole experience was such a waste of time and stressful.

We just decided to go with neighbor's friend by paying reasonable amount of $.

Reason of review:
Need function to rate the sitters!

Preferred solution: Let the company propose a solution

View full review
4 comments
Guest

Supposedly they are going to fix this next year 2020, but meanwhile we had a sitter trash our entire house, lose one of our pets, either steal or throw out a bunch of our property. House sitters response; they will put a negative warning in her file, (that nobody else will see) and if they have any other complaints they will remove her, (she still there).

Guest

Simple, ask for references from those he has sat for. Ask how pets were treated, home respected, and be sure to let your neighbors know and meet the sitter.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1599304

However as in our Case, this horrendous sitter demanded and threatened us if we did not give her a positive endorsement, and only positive endorsements they wish to share would be seen.

Guest

Wow! When I saw advertisements for house sitting services I thought it was a such a good idea.

But, then I questioned the vetting process. Is there a vetting process? I questioned. Will the sitters agree to a police background check (meaning going to a police station and submitting fingerprints)?

I questioned. Sounds like a nice service, if people were good and honest and reliable. I somehow think it's a perfect opportunity for slackers, desperados, and evil doers in this day and age. Not a safe bet.

It's like rolling dice. Best go not go away or find a family member or neighbor to watch your house for you.

View more comments (3)
Tehya Dyl

No-Show, Dishonest Sitter

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - The reviewer says the site blocks negative reviews.
  • - Ellen postponed two days, harassed a neighbor, lied about backup, and sent a nasty text.

I don't recommend this site because they don't allow homeowners to post negative reviews. The sitter "Ellen" sounded great on her profile, phone calls, and emails.

She was a nightmare. She postponed her arrival by two days. She harassed my neighbor by phone, expecting my neighbor to care for my dog until she got there. She then lied to me and claimed I'd told her the neighbor would be a back up.

I was 2000 miles away and had to have a friend go into my place and remove my dog because this sitter kept pushing back her arrival date, finally by two days. When I told her that I had made other arrangements and that she should not come, would have no way to get in, etc., she sent a nasty text. I contacted service, all by email. They said she denied everything and gave her a warning.

I suggested they allow negative reviews and resonses by both parties (as most online services do).

The customer service people seemed naive and didn't seem to get it...that this person put my dog's life at risk. Thank goodness I found out and was able to make other arrangements.

Reason of review:
Poor customer service
View full review
1 comment
Guest

I am considering signing on with the service as a sitter. There are bad apples in every batch.

Just wondering your thoughts, from my view point, what do I need to look for? Thanks!

Anonymous

Unable to leave review for dishonest sitter

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Sitter left 20 days early, stole cash and supplies, dumped my cat.
  • - The site doesn't allow negative reviews; the sitter was warned.

Hired a pet sitter through this site who left 20 days early, stole cash and supplies from home and dumped my cat in boarding. I had to cut my trip short and pay airline fees and boarding costs.

Web site doesnt allow negative reviews. Sitter naturally denied my account therefore gets a warning and will only be taken off site if another person complains.

As there is no reason for me to lie and Im the one who absorbed all the cost and worry this is inadequate. Beware, you could get a sitter that steals and wouldn't know it unless you're the second complaint!

Reason of review:
Poor customer service
View full review
2 comments
Guest

I am considering signing on with the service as a sitter. There are bad apples in every batch.

Just wondering your thoughts, from my view point, what do I need to look for? Thanks!

Guest

You're right. The problem is they don't allow negative reviews!

They just give a warning.

I had a terrible experience with a sitter who didn't show up to care for my dog. I was 2000 miles away and had to have a friend go into my place to get my dog.

View more comments (1)
Lori G Snz

This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ

Verified Reviewer

BEWARE OF SITTER REVIEWS!!!

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Sitters cared for cats but left the home in a disaster.
  • - Items were ruined, stained, non-repairable.
  • - The site lets sitters dictate reviews; all positive.
Updated by user Dec 08, 2016

Multiple attempts to have my review posted remain unsuccessful. Sitters still have the final word on which reviews are posted to their profile, thereby rendering the company's review system dangerously flawed and biased in favor of sitters. Homeowners seeking sitters have NO IDEA that all negative reviews are screened and rejected by sitters, rendering reviews untrustworthy.

Original review Nov 08, 2016

We stumbled upon the house sitting service website, did our due diligence and found what we believed was a lovely couple to house/pet sit during our month-long trip. While they took great care of our felines, unfortunately the sitters left our home in a disastrous state with many items ruined, stained and non-repairable.

But even worse than that is that the site permits their registered SITTERS dictate what reviews are and are not posted on their profile, which is why every review on the site is positive, which in turn gives homeowners a false sense of security when hiring a sitter via the site.

I have had multiple email conversations with the company regarding our experience and my strong desire to post a fair and honest review to no avail. Suffice to say, the review system is seriously flawed and completely untrustworthy.

Loss:
$1200
Reason of review:
SCREENED AND BIASED REVEIW SYSTEM

Preferred solution: The right to post a fair and HONEST review

View full review

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article