PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Pick N Save and Woodmans Market as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Pick N Save
Woodmans Market

Pick N Save and Woodmans Market Overview

Total reviews
184
31
Company responses
0
0
Issues resolved
3
1

Pick N Save was first mentioned on PissedConsumer on Aug 16, 2010 and since then this brand received 184 reviews. It is 153 reviews more than Woodmans Market received since Apr 12, 2011. According to received "Issue Resolved" consumers' votes, a consumer is more likely to resolve issues with Woodmans Market customer support team than with Pick N Save customer service.

Pick N Save and Woodmans Market Consumer Ratings

Rank
91 out of 720 in Food Stores category
21 out of 720 in Food Stores category
Product or Service Quality
78 in category
61 in category
Discounts and Special Offers
69 in category
21 in category
Customer service
64 in category
26 in category

According to consumer ratings and reviews, Woodmans Market ranks 70 points higher in the Food Stores category than Pick N Save. People gave Pick N Save 2.1 stars for Product or Service Quality criterion in Food Stores category and it is 60 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. At the same time, Woodmans Market was rated 2.3 stars for Product or Service Quality criterion in this category and it is 77 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. If we look at Discounts and Special Offers criterion, than we see that Woodmans Market has a higher rating than Pick N Save. Regarding Customer service criterion, consumers gave Pick N Save 1.9 stars and it is 54% greater than other in category. Woodmans Market however was rated 2.4 stars and it is 81% greater than other in category.

Pick N Save and Woodmans Market Rating Details

Product or Service Quality
2.1 (85 reviews)
2.3 (16 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

They need to learn they don't have to ask for ID for people clearly over 50 years old!!

PissedConsumer1711170

Used self checkout in your Sun Prairie store. It was shorty before 8am, with only one register open. Got down to the last 4 items in my cart a cashier comes over and grabbed an item that was already scanned and made me rescan it. I was like why it was already scanned. She went on to say if it was...

Troy T
Customer service
1.9 (84 reviews)
2.4 (17 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

Went shopping on Friday September 27th 2019,I had my digital coupons loaded to my Card.Got my items and went to self check out.Because self check out was the only thing open. Clerk tried to help me,but called Pricing Coordinator (Cathy)to my register because digital coupons not working.Pricing...

PissedConsumer1670535

...Woodman's is too big of a store to be pulling the out of stock routine with the customers. If more customers requesting delivery would cancel their orders when they repeatedly get out of stock message, maybe Woodman's would start taking the customer seriously..

Dianne D
Discounts and Special Offers
2.3 (84 reviews)
3.1 (15 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

We went for the sales items which were few and far between. The steaks that were on sale were scarce and the few we had to choose from ended up being tougher than old shoes and these were t bones and porterhouses. When checking out the girl charged us twice the amount for the charcoal which was...

Twyla K

We've shopped there for years and enjoy the great variety of ethnic ingredients and their produce.Sometime after they built their huge storage facility began having problems. If you buy the Dole brand heads of lettuce, plan on using withing 2-3 days or risk spoilage. Thought it was a temporary...

PissedConsumer1443147

Pick N Save and Woodmans Market Pros and Cons

Pros
  • Location
  • Finding everythign i wanted in one store
  • Wed and sat coupons
  • Price
  • Selection
Cons
  • Spoiled food
  • Customer service
  • Worthless management
  • Read comment
  • Disorganised layout
  • Terrible customer service

Pick N Save and Woodmans Market Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews
5

Hi, The last 2 weeks we have NOT gotten our Pick'n Save ads in the mail. I am extremely disappointed. Last week the...

5

I love Woodman's. Every time I have asked for help employees are more then happy to help even when I say just tell me...

Pick N Save and Woodmans Market Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews
1

put a roast in my cart. Printed sign in bold numbers $3.49 a pound. Written small with magic marker with a $80.00 orde...

1

Fulfillment of delivery order for senior disabled, items omitted because picker was tooooo lazy to look for items. I...

Pick N Save and Woodmans Market Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews
2.8

They need to learn they don't have to ask for ID for people clearly over 50 years old!!

Read all 184 reviews

I placed an order yesterday - 11-24 - had trouble placing order on the computer - have made many phone calls to nice...

Read all 31 reviews

Pick N Save and Woodmans Market Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Pick N Save Customer Care (31 reviews)
  • Pick N Save Cashier (14 reviews)
  • Pick N Save Manager (13 reviews)
  • Woodmans Market Cashier (3 reviews)
  • Woodmans Market Delivery Service (3 reviews)
  • Woodmans Market Customer Care (2 reviews)