PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Martha Stewart Living
Plow And Hearth

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Overview

Total reviews 205 42
Company responses 0 0
Issues resolved 4 0

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Consumer Ratings

Rank
76 out of 491 in Periodicals & Publishing category
109 out of 334 in Supermarkets and Malls category
Product or Service Quality
65 in category
90 in category
Value for money
57 in category
97 in category
Customer service
51 in category
83 in category
Diversity of Products or Services
90 in category
60 in category

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Rating Details

Product or Service Quality
2.3 (40 reviews)
1.4 (17 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

Martha Stewart i try yo contact cuayomer service or somebody to have a response to make my claim for like almost like two months I write like five emails I try to call like more than five times and I never got an answer I bought table cut made with Wood at Macys on Black Friday and I just use it...

Read full review

After emailing customer service three times, getting a different explanation each time, the hardware still has not been delivered. I was even refunded the $20 extra delivery fee! It seems that it would be an easy fix. Just take the hardware we needed from one of the benches you have in stock and...

Read full review
Value for money
2.5 (39 reviews)
1.4 (18 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...The ones that come with the furniture are not worth the money..

Read full review

My daughter bought a Mayfair Bonded Leather Wing Chair and Ottoman with the Christmas money I gave her in 2014. The first year was fine but beginning in the second year, the layer of leather (microscopic) began to peel away from the backing. Each year it has gotten worse as you can see from the...

Read full review
Customer service
2.1 (37 reviews)
1.3 (24 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

Terrible customer service. I tried to get a replacement part and nobody seems to know where to refer me to get the replacement leg for the rocking chair..

Read full review

I contacted Plow and Hearth, Customer Service last week to inquire about the status of my order. I explained to the Customer Service I was suppose to receive the order on May 18 but for some reason, UPS had not delivered the package. The customer service tech promised that she would call me back...

Read full review
Diversity of Products or Services
2.5 (33 reviews)
2.6 (16 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

Im not a customer and Never requested the magazines. I want a full refund!

Read full review

...I absolutely would stay away from purchasing products from this company, you will not recieve your product and they will pass blame and promise to refund you, but you will not recieve your refund. Buyer beware..

Read full review

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Pros and Cons

Pros
  • Variety of infomration
  • To cancel
  • Needs to be canceled
  • What i was buying
  • Seemed easy to order e-gift card
  • Quality merchandise
Cons
  • No answer on phone to canceal oil
  • No amswer on phone
  • I should be able to cancel easily
  • Poor return contact
  • Poor quality
  • Poor customer service

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews
5

I am late responding to renewal request for Living.

Read full review
3.3

I have purchased a number of items from Plow and Hearth and recently ordered a small piece of furniture and 3 cushions....

Read full review
5

It will be resent.
Thank you

Read full review
No votes

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews
1

I purchased Martha Stewart Living kitchen cabinets with Home Depot in Atascadero, CA in May 2014. The upper cabinets we...

Read full review
1

Advertised reduced shipping costs. Was charged almost $22 when the shipping was suppose to be $5. P & H didn't...

Read full review
1

After one year we had a strand of lights go out. Tried everything replacing fuses and all but could not get it to work....

Read full review
1

1> Ordered 2 battery operated candelabras through Amazon. They arrived 10 days later (12/14). Both of them had a non-...

Read full review

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews
No votes

The following is a copy of the email l sent to MarthaStewartCustomerSupport on Sept 22. I have heard NOTHING back from t...

Read full review
1

A Birmingham Bench was delivered to me on July 28. When we were preparing to assemble the bench for use, we discovered t...

Read full review
1

Im not a customer and Never requested the magazines. I want a full refund!

Read full review
1

Ordered a plant may 5, 2020. Was not informed until several weeks later there order was delayed until 7/25/2020. After...

Read full review

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Martha Stewart Living Subscription (44 reviews)
  • Martha Stewart Living Christmas Tree (15 reviews)
  • Martha Stewart Living Customer Care (9 reviews)
  • Plow And Hearth Shipping Service (9 reviews)
  • Plow And Hearth Customer Care (3 reviews)
  • Plow And Hearth Prospect Hill Resin Wicker Furniture Set (1 review)