PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Martha Stewart Living
Plow And Hearth

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Overview

Total reviews
Company responses
Issues resolved

Martha Stewart Living was first mentioned on PissedConsumer on Jun 5, 2011 and since then this brand received 154 reviews. It is 119 reviews more than Plow And Hearth received since Jan 7, 2015.

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Consumer Ratings

57 out of 622 in Periodicals & Publishing category
293 out of 2128 in Furniture and Decor category
Product or Service Quality
53 in category
252 in category
Value for money
48 in category
287 in category
Customer service
42 in category
233 in category

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Rating Details

Product or Service Quality
2.4 (27 reviews)
1.5 (14 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

What a headache! I went with these cabinets because i figured Martha Stuart would stand behind her product. Its been one problem after another. The spice rack came broken, my large utility cabinet came in a different grain of wood...

Helene B

...I called P&H customer service; first the lady said that they had no record of this transaction, even when I gave her the confirmation # from the confirmation email that I got from P&H. She switched back and forth (let me check on this..

Murray G
Value for money
2.6 (27 reviews)
1.5 (15 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

I cannot find contact info. This fuse is not available at any of stores that carry the trees.

Sue C

1> Ordered 2 battery operated candelabras through Amazon. They arrived 10 days later (12/14). Both of them had a non-functioning bulb (special kind only available from P&H...of course). Called customer service who told me I had to contact Amazon because I bought them through Amazon. Called...

Customer service
2.1 (26 reviews)
1.4 (19 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...Customer service is not customer friendly..

Mary b

...climb up onto the truck and get the item off themselves AND they cannot use the liftgate to lower the item to the ground without paying an ADDITIONAL $50! Customer service is atrocious, unprofessional, in serious need of training and basically a waste of time. I did not believe what I was being told so I opted to clarify...

Elvira J

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Pros and Cons

  • To cancel
  • Needs to be canceled
  • Very good articles
  • What i was buying
  • Seemed easy to order e-gift card
  • Ease of ordering
  • No answer on phone to canceal oil
  • No amswer on phone
  • I should be able to cancel easily
  • Poor return contact
  • Lack of customer service and support for their products
  • Complete misrepresentation of product

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews

I am late responding to renewal request for Living.


I don't know if this would be considered bait and switch, but Plow and Hearth (http://www.plowhearth.com) promised a...

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews

I purchased Martha Stewart Living kitchen cabinets with Home Depot in Atascadero, CA in May 2014. The upper cabinets we...


Advertised reduced shipping costs. Was charged almost $22 when the shipping was suppose to be $5. P & H didn't...

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews

I had the tree only one year and only half the lights work and after check the fuses and the bulbs after many hours. I...

Read all 154 reviews

UGG SLIPPERS re free shipping today--top of the checkout page says 20% off $50 purchase with promotion code as listed....

Read all 35 reviews

Martha Stewart Living and Plow And Hearth Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Martha Stewart Living Subscription (25 reviews)
  • Martha Stewart Living Christmas Tree (14 reviews)
  • Martha Stewart Living Customer Care (8 reviews)
  • Plow And Hearth Shipping Service (8 reviews)
  • Plow And Hearth Customer Care (2 reviews)
  • Plow And Hearth Curved Firewood Rack (1 review)