Thumbtack vs HomeAdvisor
PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.
Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor Overview
Total reviews | 3960 | 379 |
Company responses | 351 | 114 |
Issues resolved | 13 | 9 |
Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor Consumer Ratings
Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor Rating Details
Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor Pros and Cons
- Concept
- Idea
- Ease of use
- Wool being pulled over my eyes
- Smooth talker
- No pros
- Lost money
- No accountability
- Customer service
- Fraud
- Customer service
- Suck
Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor Most Positive Reviews
I am not having access to speak to the client due to my criminal record as I have not attached a photo ID and it is...
HomeAdvisor rips off their own employees for leads that don't even pan out!! I only had 2 jobs and have been charged a...
Thumbtack is not fake. If you take the time to read the tips they send, completely setup your profile, and write a...
I wasnt told i had to pay for leads (im a contractor) so when i was charged that i decided to end it with Home Advisor....
Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor Most Critical Reviews
I have been struggling with your lead charging system. I have been hired only 4 times yet I have been charged for over 5...
I hired 3 pros from Homeadvisor but one doesn't show anywhere except in my Fav Pros which they say is no proof I hired...
I need refund I didnt receive any back from the customer so you just take the money and no one answer me back so I need...
As a contractor of Twenty plus years I have never experienced such a RIP-OFF of contractors by HomeAdvisor (HA). I...
Thumbtack and HomeAdvisor Latest Reviews
Was kick off thumbtack now i can reach no one and every time I call i get sent to to text messages and can get not...
Angi leads/Home Advisor did not even do my onboarding every time I called the guy they gave me the number for on...
Who is doing a lawsuit!!!???! I've lost ALOT OF MONEY AND ALL OF MY BUSINESS ON THUMBTACK AND IM IN THE NYC AREA!!!...
I give 150% to my job at all times always on time love what I do. I communicate very well with my customers. I always...
Both are absolutely terrible
Product or Service Quality
Both charge ridiculous amounts and should be indicted for criminal enterprise
I have something else to compare
Thumbtack used to be head and shoulders above everyone in the field. Now, their greed has cost them all integrity. DO NOT USE EITHER
Home advisor is much better with customer service
Product or Service Quality
The leads they offer are not very helpful and expensive also.
I have something else to compare
They are now open to working with pros directly
They seem to be very similar based on the ratings.
Home Advisor does not handle disc jockey services. Thanks for the effort though!
How would you compare Thumbtack vs HomeAdvisor?
Worse
Product or Service Quality
Same. Poor.
Home advisor is more relaxed and calm. They answer your questions and try there best to help.
Product or Service Quality
Home advisor doesn't ask for money up front.
They provide the service first then ask for compensation.
Aside from not being able to actually โtalkโ to someone & both only giving credits, not actual cold hard cash back, even when many leads arenโt won, and I disputed almost all lost leads against them, THUMBTACK is definitely better
Product or Service Quality
I feel thumbtack is still a bit more legitimate, lead wise.
I have something else to compare
Plus, theyโre leads are a bit less expensive, and even though I did dispute many leads, Iโm hoping they deactivate my account because they really are the lesser of evils. Lol