PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Hercules Tires and Toyo Tires as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Hercules Tires
Toyo Tires

Hercules Tires and Toyo Tires Overview

Total reviews
Company responses
Issues resolved

Hercules Tires was first mentioned on PissedConsumer on Jul 5, 2008 and since then this brand received 99 reviews. It is 87 reviews more than Toyo Tires received since Sep 2, 2008.

Hercules Tires and Toyo Tires Consumer Ratings

40 out of 519 in Auto Parts and Accessories category
101 out of 519 in Auto Parts and Accessories category
Price Affordability
41 in category
89 in category
Product or Service Quality
47 in category
76 in category
Value for money
41 in category
90 in category

According to consumer ratings and reviews, Hercules Tires ranks 61 points higher in the Auto Parts and Accessories category than Toyo Tires. People gave Hercules Tires 2.6 stars for Price Affordability criterion in Auto Parts and Accessories category and it is 90 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. At the same time, Toyo Tires was rated 2 stars for Price Affordability criterion in this category and it is 42 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. If we look at Product or Service Quality criterion, than we see that Hercules Tires has a higher rating than Toyo Tires. Regarding Value for money criterion, consumers gave Hercules Tires 2.2 stars and it is 69% greater than other in category. Toyo Tires however was rated 1.2 stars and it is 68% worse than other in category.

Hercules Tires and Toyo Tires Rating Details

Price Affordability
2.6 (33 reviews)
2 (5 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

The tire shop, which I trusted, because of having replaced my brakes and shocks at a reasonable price, insisted that the Hercules tires were good quality tires. After they install them they insisted that it did not need an alignment since it drove straight before, however it pulled hard to the...

Leo L

My 265 40 R22 were roaring so bad I was sure that the rear hub bearings were bad so I changed them isn’t fix the roar . I take to my tire man and he says it’s the tires.. Damn . Still deep tread. These tires were NOT cheap to buy .i took them to get them rotated to see if it might help the roar...

Henry R
Product or Service Quality
1.8 (33 reviews)
1.3 (6 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

One service rep thought the situation was funny!! Didn't realize 4 defective tires that could cause an accident was humorous! When I finally got to the manager's line, I was disconnected!! Filing a claim with the BBB and AG. I'm shocked that a customer service rep would laugh about defective...

Shelly L

...Local TOYO dealers and Ford service Dept (Based on TOYO info) say there is nothing they can do. 95% or better of all miles driven have been highway miles. Pictures of a *** TOYO tire with 30K miles as compared to a Michelin tire from my 1 Ton dually with 85,000 miles tells the story...

Value for money
2.2 (31 reviews)
1.2 (6 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

Extremely pleased with the customer service from Hercules Tires. All emails and calls were responded to in a timely manner. Webster at adjustments was particularly kind, professional and very responsive. I will continue to be a loyal and happy customer. Thanks......

Antonio R

...I have used and spent a lot of money on toyo tires in the past with no issues. Currently running 295/30/24 toyo proxes on my new 2018 Dodge Durango RT. Unfortunately I had a large stress crack on the side wall of 1 tire...

Richard A

Hercules Tires and Toyo Tires Pros and Cons

  • Price
  • Performance
  • How they looked
No votes
  • Quality
  • Not safe to drive
  • Quality and no responce
  • Defective tire & lack of concern
  • Life and my families life being in jeopardy

Hercules Tires and Toyo Tires Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews

While most only post complaints on sites like these we thought you might like to hear from someone that is happy with th...

No votes

Hercules Tires and Toyo Tires Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews

Bought a set of Hercules Terra Trac A/T's, one tire took more weight to balance than the other three. Tire vibrates on...


Tread wear is severely bad due to defective materials in these tires. Local TOYO dealers and Ford service Dept (Based...

Hercules Tires and Toyo Tires Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews

Purchased 4 brand new tires and all 4 tires dry rotted after only 8 months with over 75% tread. Company only offering...

Read all 99 reviews

New Corolla came with these tires, Very unsafe tires at speeds over 60 mph. Had car checked out and strictly a tire...

Read all 12 reviews

Hercules Tires and Toyo Tires Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Hercules Tires Tires (65 reviews)
  • Hercules Tires Terra Trac At Ii Tires (5 reviews)
  • Toyo Tires Tires (11 reviews)
  • Toyo Tires Proxes St Ii Tires (1 review)