GEICO vs Progressive Insurance
PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions.
Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about GEICO and Progressive Insurance as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.
GEICO and Progressive Insurance Overview
|
Total reviews |
1270
|
1007
|
|
Company responses |
0 |
1 |
|
Issues resolved |
11 |
3 |
AdvertisementsSome advertisers may pay us for this ad to appear on our website or provide us with a referral fee. Our content is free because we may earn a commission if you purchase products after clicking ads on our website.
GEICO and Progressive Insurance Consumer Ratings
Rank
154
out of 1079 in Insurance category
155
out of 1079 in Insurance category
Customer service
146
in category
No votes
Product or Service Quality
116
in category
No votes
Billing Practices
118
in category
No votes
Website
103
in category
No votes
GEICO and Progressive Insurance Rating Details
Customer service
No votes
Reviewer's quote
...To get through to a speaking customer service agent has been a nightmare. You both need to change your 800 numbers so that a real person can be reached. I will not recommend Assurant or Geico to anyone for service..
Read full review
...Spoke with customer service and they were rude and argumentative, not willing to help at all. Maybe they should think about putting more money into customer service than into their advertising budget..
Read full review
Product or Service Quality
No votes
Reviewer's quote
...they just assumed he was driving our cars and did an automatic price hike, not covering his car nor giving a quote, To correct the error, we called customer service who was condescending and arrogant,demanding that we send them proof he had another insurance policy. I told them that why did they put someone on our policy that was not authorized, No answer. It was pretty much "take it or leave it"...
Read full review
I told him I was happy to send him the write up from the dealership even though I was there when the service advisor from the dealership spoke to him about the SAME information. He said if he knew what was wrong with it then he could speak with his supervisor and review the claim again. I sent over...
Read full review
Billing Practices
No votes
Reviewer's quote
RUN as FAST as YOU CAN FROM GEICO----UNFAIR and DECEPTIVE TRADE PRACTICES!!!!!!---NASTY LOW CLASS PEOPLE (probably live in the hood)--never made a dime in their life---LIVE OFF OF OTHERS--To STUPID TO WORK FOR THEMSELVES!
Read full review
I paid the poiicy in full for 6 months that progressives billing required 2 days after the policy is paid in full they wanted an additional 54. 00 dollars because of an address change that they already had in previous records via previous corresponding e-mails dated 3/2020 and prior to said date,...
Read full review
Reviewer's quote
...As a fun fact, I went on their website and got a quote and can you guess what happened? YUP, it was lower than what I'm paying now. Same company, same person, 2 quotes. How is this even legal? Cancelling these *** today..
Read full review
ALL from your website thinking how wonderful to bundle everything but now on my auto renewal I'm uprated to $200 because in CA it has to be underwritten by you specifically. How does your customer have control over this if they are writing it through YOU, YOUR website!! And it has to be another...
Read full review
AdvertisementsSome advertisers may pay us for this ad to appear on our website or provide us with a referral fee. Our content is free because we may earn a commission if you purchase products after clicking ads on our website.
GEICO and Progressive Insurance Pros and Cons
Pros
- Price
- Horribble
- Good at taking your money
- To angry to answer this
- Simple to join
- Very dissatisfied
Cons
- Customer service
- Inability to resolve issues
- Poor treatment of customers
- Customer service
- Bad service
- Unwilling to compromise and blamed me
GEICO and Progressive Insurance Most Positive Reviews
Top rated reviews
I have been an insured driver for 46 years with no accidents or insurance claims. I backed into my daughters Honda in...
Read full review
Had to come to NY from Florida because my mother was on her death dead and because I was here from Florida I recited a...
Read full review
I received a registered letter from GEICO that they are cancelling my policy because i have 3 no fault claims in the...
Read full review
This is one of the worst insurance companies to put your trust in. Everything is good while they take your money every...
Read full review
GEICO and Progressive Insurance Most Critical Reviews
Lowest rated reviews
A Geiko insured person backed into me. geiko emailed me and accepted responsibility 1 month ago. I got car repaired. I...
Read full review
If I could could not give a star, I would. I have to agree with all the complaints on here regarding Progressive...
Read full review
In January my daughter was to get her drivers license coming soon. I called the local Geico office and talked to Lori....
Read full review
I have allstate motorcycle , in ten my coverage will be over so i called to progressive , I asked same coverage as my a...
Read full review
GEICO and Progressive Insurance Latest Reviews
Recent published reviews
Company rep stated that if I wasnt enrolled in auto pay that I have to pay two months upfront, I explained to her that...
Read full review
Hate all of your commercial. They are downgrading your company. Please STOP. Especially the motor. They really suck
Read full review
I have been charged by Geico and Assurant insurance for my monthly renters insurance. I have had to call both companies...
Read full review
their nasty singing with a bunch of them in a group singing in the commercial drives me up the freaking wall makes me...
Read full review
GEICO and Progressive Insurance Products and Services
Most reviewed product and services
-
Geico Auto Insurance
(375 reviews)
-
Geico Auto Claim
(172 reviews)
-
Geico Claim
(152 reviews)
-
Progressive Insurance Auto Insurance
(224 reviews)
-
Progressive Insurance Commercial
(160 reviews)
-
Progressive Insurance Auto Claim
(142 reviews)
How would you compare GEICO vs Progressive Insurance?
GEICO is hands down better than Progressive. Several years ago a GEICO client hit me and GEICO paid everything.
There was a smaller invoice that they were refusing for a bit, but they ended up paying it. Things got mixed up and I’m not even sure if they owed it. But they even brought the check to me in the end. It was a couple hundred less than Progressive owes me now.
And Progressive is tagging fault on me. Where GEICO didn’t. A bit different situation, but still similar. The attitude of Progressive is also horrible compared to GEICO.
I’m certainly inspired to stay with the insurance I currently have. Stay away from Progressive. They’re bad news.
Here is my story. www.progressiveinsurancescam.wordpress.com
One thing I can say Progressive don't like pay always try to low Ball one. Some one hit my car that was insured by Progressive.The adjuster said my car was only worth 6,647.24 but Kelly Blue Book say it worth between 5,719.00- 8,190.00 take into account small scratches an other flowes thin he want to take another 2,270,65 off the 6,647,00 now the car is only worth ,4,000.an change progressive two bight out of the apple,plus progressive don't want to pay to get the car back to ARK from Atlanta Ga, an no Rental,Im a 70yrs old Disable Veteran
From what I have read and experienced ....any insurance company would be better than Progressive Insurance. It appears that no insurance company is perfect.
I have only met one person that has Progressive that is satisfied. And I have my doubts that that person is in touch with reality.