PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about First Alert and Gardall as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

First Alert
Gardall

First Alert and Gardall Overview

Total reviews 128 0
Company responses 0 0
Issues resolved 1 0

First Alert and Gardall Consumer Ratings

Rank
75 out of 248 in Security and Protection Services category
206 out of 248 in Security and Protection Services category
Reliability
62 in category
No votes
Product or Service Quality
65 in category
No votes
Value for money
63 in category
No votes
Price Affordability
38 in category
No votes

First Alert and Gardall Rating Details

Reliability
1.1 (57 reviews)
No votes
Reviewer's quote

Bought two at Costco September 2019 The P1210 in the bedroom kept randomly beeping so I took it off the ceiling and beat it with a hammer. After a few more months about a year, the other one in the office is going off occasionally. Three beeps three times then later in the day the same thing. No...

Read full review

No items

Product or Service Quality
1.2 (56 reviews)
No votes
Reviewer's quote

...As it's a one time use product, it was a waste of money..

Read full review

No items

Value for money
1.3 (43 reviews)
No votes
Reviewer's quote

...Waste of time and money - Don't buy!..

Read full review

No items

Price Affordability
2.5 (37 reviews)
No votes
Reviewer's quote

I'm on my 4th, 10 year guaranteed smoke alarm. three are replacements for the ones that went off prematurely. The last one survived 1 month before going off without cause. NEVER will I buy from First Alert again. July 2020.

Read full review

No items

First Alert and Gardall Pros and Cons

Pros
  • Idea that the sealed lithium battery would last 10 years
  • Brand and 10 year battery
  • Supposed 10 year battery life
No votes
Cons
  • That it did not meet product life expectations or guarantee
  • P1210 smoke detector
  • Lousy and disappointing product this time
No votes

First Alert and Gardall Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews
5

THE assitant that helped me was very polite and helped me with my problem. She is sending me a new unit. Would...

Read full review
No votes
5

Add me to the list! What a nightmare! Also bought a 2 pack at Costco and one of them malfunctioned yesterday. Called...

Read full review
No votes

First Alert and Gardall Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews
1

Purchased / installed 3 pack in Jan 2018. It’s now the end of June 2018 . 2 of 3 have gone off for no reason .

Read full review
No votes
1

I purchased two First Alert model no. P1210 in january 2017. Supposed to last ten years. Now its a throw away. Don't...

Read full review
No votes

First Alert and Gardall Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews
1

Bought two at Costco September 2019 The P1210 in the bedroom kept randomly beeping so I took it off the ceiling and...

Read full review
No votes
2.8

I'm on my 4th, 10 year guaranteed smoke alarm. three are replacements for the ones that went off prematurely. The last...

Read full review
No votes

First Alert and Gardall Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • First Alert P1210 Smoke Detector (96 reviews)
  • First Alert Smoke Detector (13 reviews)
  • First Alert Safe (2 reviews)