Doterra vs Melaleuca: which one is better? @ Pissed Consumer

PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Doterra and Melaleuca as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Start a new comparison

Doterra

4.0

Melaleuca

3.0

Doterra

Melaleuca

Doterra and Melaleuca Overview

Total reviews

737

Company responses

Issues resolved

Melaleuca was first mentioned on PissedConsumer on Jan 4, 2008 and since then this brand received 737 reviews. It is 714 reviews more than Doterra received since Apr 5, 2014.

Doterra and Melaleuca Consumer Ratings

Rank

19 out of 992 in Health and Beauty category

26 out of 992 in Health and Beauty category

Website

30 in category

32 in category

Price Affordability

22 in category

60 in category

Diversity of Products or Services

13 in category

29 in category

According to consumer ratings and reviews, Doterra ranks 7 points higher in the Health and Beauty category than Melaleuca. People gave Doterra 3.7 stars for Website criterion in Health and Beauty category and it is 171 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. At the same time, Melaleuca was rated 3.3 stars for Website criterion in this category and it is 169 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. If we look at Price Affordability criterion, than we see that Doterra has a higher rating than Melaleuca. Regarding Diversity of Products or Services criterion, consumers gave Doterra 4.5 stars and it is 94% greater than other in category. Melaleuca however was rated 3.3 stars and it is 86% greater than other in category.

Doterra and Melaleuca Rating Details

Website

3.7 (10 reviews)

3.3 (210 reviews)

Reviewer's quote

...Their website needs some work. It is hard to get to the join area to get the wholesale pricing when I went in to shop first. ..

Gerardo

...This is their 2018 Income Disclosure Statement from their own website. As you can see, you literally only have a 0. 8% chance of averaging $23,000 a year...

Roxanne C

Diversity of Products or Services

4.5 (10 reviews)

3.3 (146 reviews)

Reviewer's quote

Love all the products I have tried so far , after a year and half of use I came to the conclusion that they are honest, great and safe product and decided to join as a business builder. So far I’m happy with my decision ..

PissedConsumer1186883

Sugar (different special name for it, of course) in the Vitamin C powder (sort of like Airborne or EmergenC), the hair products (conditioner, shampoo, serums, etc. ) ALL have "fragrance" or "parfum" listed in the ingredients (which is a known cause of hormone disruptors and allergens, harmful...

PissedConsumer1762370

Price Affordability

3.8 (10 reviews)

2.9 (206 reviews)

Reviewer's quote

Be advised!!!Signed up for this as I use essential oils, liked the quality of duTerras. However it was not until the 11th hour that I came to realise their peculiar practice ie: your order becomes default and remains in your basket (a little like your favourites) and one must diarise a date every...

Maxine B

There is an option to purchase without the required 35 points however you do not get the discounted price. I have been using the products for over a year and have not been disappointed in any of them the supplements, skin care, fiberwise, essential oils, deodorants shampoos, protein bars,...

PissedConsumer1303916

Doterra and Melaleuca Pros and Cons

Pros

Products and the fast shipping
Great customer service when needed
Very well satisfied

High quality product
Cleaning products
Products

Cons

Corporate protection of advocates
Paid for oils were not delivered id 1596968
Paid for oils no delevery

Commitment to a monthly order
Monthly commitment
Deceptive misleading miserable

Doterra and Melaleuca Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews

We've been using essential oils for 20+ years in our home an with our family. I'd had just enough good experiences that...

I have been shopping with melaleuca since Dec. of 2006 almost 8 yrs now. Went in as the biggest skeptic in the world. I...

Doterra and Melaleuca Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews

a fake BOGO - and then doTERRA management covered up for them (by sending to me the promised items) and are now making i...

I requested to the same person who invite me to view what Melaleuca products was, I explaind to him to please requested...

Doterra and Melaleuca Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews

The whole household has been sick this winter, with a couple of new strains of viruses that seem to reinfect and keep...

Read all 23 reviews

2.2

Honestly, the reps/customer service of course were very sweet BUT there are several issues with this "wellness" company....

Read all 737 reviews

Doterra and Melaleuca Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services

Doterra Customer Care (4 reviews)
Doterra Shipping Service (3 reviews)

Melaleuca Membership (139 reviews)
Melaleuca Customer Care (55 reviews)
Melaleuca Vitamins (32 reviews)

How would you compare Doterra vs Melaleuca?

Customer service

Product or Service Quality

I have something else to compare

I have read and agree to the Pissed Consumer Terms of Service

Share your opinion

Anonymous Cyndi Aug 28, 2018 #1548620

I use both companies and I like them both. I use more Melaleuca products and think they are excellent.

4 0

Doterra vs …

Melaleuca vs …