PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Clairol and Garnier as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Clairol
2.0
Garnier
1.9
Clairol
Garnier

Clairol and Garnier Overview

Total reviews 788 357
Company responses 0 0
Issues resolved 4 1

Clairol and Garnier Consumer Ratings

Rank
160 out of 906 in Cosmetics and Personal Care category
192 out of 906 in Cosmetics and Personal Care category
Product or Service Quality
188 in category
183 in category
Value for money
122 in category
128 in category
Reliability
122 in category
143 in category
Price Affordability
87 in category
100 in category

Clairol and Garnier Rating Details

Product or Service Quality
1.6 (243 reviews)
1.6 (123 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...The woman told me she could not tell what store I could fond the product at so I could go there and buy it . After all that was my whole purpose for calling her today . So no, I'm not happy...

Read full review

I went crazy thinking about what it could be until I used this product in my daughters hair and she broke out as well we went to the doctor panicking It has the back of my ears, neck, and hairline crusty ,scaly, and itchy burning terribly. it is embarrassing on the back of my neck I have pics and...

Read full review
Value for money
2.1 (201 reviews)
2 (113 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...I have spent extra money that I had budgeted elsewhere to fix something that I should not have had fix to begin with. Never again will I purchase Nice n Easy. IF IT ISNT BROKEN, DONT FIX IT!! 0 stars is what this is worth!!..

Read full review

I bought 4 boxes of Garnier Olia Bold hair dye in the color 8.22 Medium Rose Gold. I dyed it like normal and when I went to go brush and dry my hair I could already tell something was wrong. Turns out after going through all the work of dying my hair, WHICH IS DOWN TO MY BUTT, none of the color...

Read full review
Reliability
1.7 (197 reviews)
1.6 (101 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

I have a hot roller set that I have used almost daily for over 25 years. It has exceeded my expectations! You should start a marketing campaign featuring your lifetime lovely ladies. Thank you! Hoping for another 25 years...

Read full review

I purchased Garnier Sleek and Shine Combo on amazon and was excited to use it until I had the worst head, body and ear itching that I have ever experienced in my life.I need to research all of the ingredients in this shampoo, because there is something in it that causes hives. Very upset customer.

Read full review
Price Affordability
3 (189 reviews)
2.7 (104 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...Luckily, I was able to purchase this on sale because I would be really upset if I paid full price. It is definitely not worth the cost. I do not plan on buying Natural Instincts or any Clairol product again..

Read full review

...Now on eBay they are selling it for a ridiculous price. Do you have any in stock there,? If so I will buy a bunch. Please let me know...

Read full review

Clairol and Garnier Pros and Cons

Pros
  • Old nice and easy formula
  • Old nice n easy product
  • Nice n easy original formula
  • Product is an outright rip off
  • Smells nice
  • Smells good
Cons
  • Nice n easy new formula
  • New formula
  • New product that the just changed
  • Losing my hair
  • No compensation for damage caused
  • Hair falling out

Clairol and Garnier Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews
5

I have always and only used nice n easy blue black hair dye and will continue to do so in future as I believe it is an...

Read full review
5

I have used Garnier products (shampoos & conditioners) for more than 10 years and like them very much.

Recently I t...

Read full review
5

I’ve used this brand forever.... not any more the new one made my hair feel dirty, & limp have washed it many times noth...

Read full review
5

I first used this dye last year and absolutely loved the results. It made my hair soft, silky, strong, and thicker than...

Read full review

Clairol and Garnier Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews
1

I had an really bad experience with"Clairol Balsam Color #3!!!" Coloring my hair and the fumes burnt my FACE and...

Read full review
1

I have been using Garnier,s "Olia" hair dyes since they came on the market and just a few weeks ago i decided to try a d...

Read full review
1

I used clairol dark brown no 79. I am disgusted, my scalp, forehead and neck was burnt. My face swollen and eyes...

Read full review
1

The hair spray is VERY similar to rubbing silicone caulk into your hair !! A couple hours after you apply it , your hai...

Read full review

Clairol and Garnier Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews
4.4

I called to ask a few questions about letting the semi-permanent hair color grow out of my hair. I have used Natural...

Read full review
1

I purchased Garnier Sleek and Shine Combo on amazon and was excited to use it until I had the worst head, body and ear i...

Read full review
5

I have a hot roller set that I have used almost daily for over 25 years. It has exceeded my expectations! You should...

Read full review
1

I started washing my hair with Garnier Fructis shampoo. After a couple weeks, I noticed when I ran my hands through my...

Read full review

Clairol and Garnier Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Clairol Nice And Easy Hair Dye (358 reviews)
  • Clairol Hair Dye (157 reviews)
  • Clairol Natural Instincts Hair Dye (71 reviews)
  • Garnier Hair Dye (73 reviews)
  • Garnier Olia Hair Dye (23 reviews)
  • Garnier Shampoo (16 reviews)