PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Catholic Match and ChristianMingle as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Catholic Match

Catholic Match and ChristianMingle Overview

Total reviews
Company responses
Issues resolved

ChristianMingle was first mentioned on PissedConsumer on Jul 29, 2012 and since then this brand received 584 reviews. It is 502 reviews more than Catholic Match received since Aug 9, 2011.

Catholic Match and ChristianMingle Consumer Ratings

38 out of 239 in Dating and Social Networking category
44 out of 239 in Dating and Social Networking category
Product or Service Quality
25 in category
29 in category
18 in category
43 in category
Price Affordability
22 in category
37 in category

According to consumer ratings and reviews, Catholic Match ranks 6 points higher in the Dating and Social Networking category than ChristianMingle. People gave Catholic Match 1.7 stars for Product or Service Quality criterion in Dating and Social Networking category and it is 67 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. At the same time, ChristianMingle was rated 1.6 stars for Product or Service Quality criterion in this category and it is 63 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. If we look at Website criterion, than we see that Catholic Match has a higher rating than ChristianMingle. Regarding Price Affordability criterion, consumers gave Catholic Match 2 stars and it is 76% greater than other in category. ChristianMingle however was rated 1.7 stars and it is 60% greater than other in category.

Catholic Match and ChristianMingle Rating Details

Product or Service Quality
1.7 (31 reviews)
1.6 (191 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

I have tried three times to reach a person to speak about preferences and I keep getting tickets. I DO NOT WANT A TICKET, I WANT A PERSON. Why do you ask about preferences when you send anyone as a match? I specifically said "within 25 miles" for location and no smokers and my wishes have not been...


Screening not accurate, predators are on this site. Wait for God to send you the right person. There exists zero representatives to assist.They take your money and you never hear from them again, even after numerous attempts to remedy your accounts.

2.1 (27 reviews)
1.7 (219 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

After several revamps of the website with changes that made it more difficult to find a match, I complained on the message forum. My post was immediately shut down and people were redirected to a vaguely related thread. This seemed like an effort to silence opinions, which was later confirmed by...


Since I have been on this website for 2 wks, I have not received even one LEGITIMATE Inquiry. Every single response comes from a fake responder. They are not in the LookBook & the profiles are all similar or no profile at all..

Price Affordability
2 (26 reviews)
1.7 (128 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...Three weeks into my account, I decided to purchase the 6 months subscription for a discounted price. I viewed all the messages and there was one profile that stood out to me. I reached out to him and we had a lot of things in common...


Site is full of scammers and customer service is nonexistent!


Catholic Match and ChristianMingle Pros and Cons

No votes
  • That i learned a lesson
  • Idea
  • That they might fall off the earth
  • Customer service
  • Waste of time and money
  • There is not blocking for creeps
  • Customer service
  • False advertising
  • Unchristian billing practices

Catholic Match and ChristianMingle Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews

I have enjoyed my contacts and views. There are times in life when a little smiley or wink brightens your day. My...


Trying this site isn't a "free trial". Once they have you try it, they will quickly charge you $34.99 without notice,...

Catholic Match and ChristianMingle Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews

I subscribed and the sight took my credit card and said I was registered etc..first time I tried to get back on it said...


I payed and logged in one time. sent email to try and get my money back and was sent message of no refunds. i am now blo...

Catholic Match and ChristianMingle Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews

67% discount offer but I was charged full price.. Customer suppôt is robot.

Read all 82 reviews

Auto-renew was on, and I do not want to have my subscription anymore. Is there a way that I can stop it, and get my...

Read all 584 reviews

Catholic Match and ChristianMingle Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Catholic Match Online Dating (21 reviews)
  • Catholic Match Website (11 reviews)
  • Catholic Match Profile (8 reviews)
  • Christianmingle Membership (120 reviews)
  • Christianmingle Account (91 reviews)
  • Christianmingle Online Dating (62 reviews)