PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Caseys General Stores and Sheetz as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Caseys General Stores

Caseys General Stores and Sheetz Overview

Total reviews
Company responses
Issues resolved

Sheetz was first mentioned on PissedConsumer on Dec 4, 2010 and since then this brand received 902 reviews. It is 637 reviews more than Caseys General Stores received since Apr 27, 2010. According to received "Issue Resolved" consumers' votes, a consumer has equal chances to resolve issues with Caseys General Stores customer support team and Sheetz customer service.

Caseys General Stores and Sheetz Consumer Ratings

96 out of 623 in Food Stores category
26 out of 1073 in Fast Food category
Customer service
79 in category
21 in category
Product or Service Quality
83 in category
15 in category
63 in category
18 in category

Caseys General Stores and Sheetz Rating Details

Customer service
1.8 (130 reviews)
2.1 (355 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...This store is poorly managed and the Customer Service is terrible..


...Im very grateful that this lady showed such caring customer service and she is to be commended for an outstanding job!!! I will never forget her face and will always remember the kindness she displayed on her job. Thank you :happy:..

Product or Service Quality
2 (126 reviews)
2.5 (342 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...for cleaning windows! I complain at the stores and they say management shrugs their shoulders and does nothing to resolve this very basic problem with Casey service! I am slowly finding other sources of fuel and services! CASEY STORES need to fix this problem with the window washing plastic edges...

Don M

...Wrong customer service number on back of card..

3.3 (120 reviews)
3.5 (306 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...have the BALLS to respond! In that case I'll share that letter far and wide! I, thankfully, have the right to FREE SPEECH! If you want to work at casey's, any location, think twice! It's a wonder they have so many unhappy employees, but no one will say anything because they are afraid of losing their jobs; which is just what will happen! Copied and Pasted this so ...

Barbara a

Good morning to who this may concern I just stopped at your Sheetz location in Centre Hall Pennsylvania at about 5:15 this morning there was no coffee not one coffee pot head coffee in and all I heard from the manager was we were busy last night and I still don't have no coffee..


Caseys General Stores and Sheetz Pros and Cons

  • Gas station
  • Most employees are great
  • Price
  • Good food
  • Other sheetz
  • Good slections
  • Horrible treatment
  • Caseys customer service
  • Bad management
  • I just wrote a whole version of experience
  • Rudeness
  • Poor customer service

Caseys General Stores and Sheetz Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews

my son, a 17 year old, was hired at casey's just over a month ago. he signed some kind of paperwork regarding id'ing...


Had words with an employee couple months ago because he ran in front of my car. Had words inside of store and finally f...

Caseys General Stores and Sheetz Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews

A filthy, overly cluttered store, totally unmanaged. Employees are allowed to do and say what they please. Filled with...


When food is being prepared there is a continuing high pitch signal to let "employees" know food is ordered. I find this...

Caseys General Stores and Sheetz Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews

Ellis store the manager is very rude how she talks to employees in front of customers. Really needs to be taught some...

Read all 265 reviews

I can provide a service to sheetz and am having a hard time confirming a true line of communication. my business...

Read all 902 reviews

Caseys General Stores and Sheetz Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Caseys General Stores Manager (53 reviews)
  • Caseys General Stores Customer Care (38 reviews)
  • Caseys General Stores Cashier (12 reviews)
  • Sheetz Customer Care (141 reviews)
  • Sheetz Manager (69 reviews)
  • Sheetz Cashier (37 reviews)