PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Carols Daughter and Garnier as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Carols Daughter

Carols Daughter and Garnier Overview

Total reviews
Company responses
Issues resolved

Garnier was first mentioned on PissedConsumer on Dec 30, 2012 and since then this brand received 310 reviews. It is 212 reviews more than Carols Daughter received since Jul 15, 2008.

Carols Daughter and Garnier Consumer Ratings

180 out of 1161 in Cosmetics and Personal Care category
148 out of 1161 in Cosmetics and Personal Care category
Product or Service Quality
159 in category
155 in category
Price Affordability
159 in category
87 in category
Customer service
157 in category
97 in category

According to consumer ratings and reviews, Garnier ranks 32 points higher in the Cosmetics and Personal Care category than Carols Daughter. People gave Carols Daughter 1.6 stars for Product or Service Quality criterion in Cosmetics and Personal Care category and it is 226 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. At the same time, Garnier was rated 1.6 stars for Product or Service Quality criterion in this category and it is 230 points higher than the worst rated brand in this category. If we look at Price Affordability criterion, than we see that Garnier has a higher rating than Carols Daughter. Regarding Customer service criterion, consumers gave Carols Daughter 1.3 stars and it is 59% greater than other in category. Garnier however was rated 1.7 stars and it is 75% greater than other in category.

Carols Daughter and Garnier Rating Details

Product or Service Quality
1.6 (34 reviews)
1.6 (105 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

I was so excited about the product that I didnt want to believe that it was the Almond and other milk conditioners that damaged my hair and scalp. It seemed to be free of harsh chemicals however there clearly are other chemicals in these Carols Daughter products which were/are strong enough to pull...


...The Colorfast is a much better product. I thought the oils in the Olia would be better for my hair, so I am very disappointed, especially for a Garnier product. Not sure if I will buy Garnier again..

Price Affordability
2 (31 reviews)
2.7 (91 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...There are MUCH better products and they are at a better price point. DON'T believe the hype, DON'T believe the PAID testimonies. A class action claim should be forthcoming..


I purchased Garnier Fructis Sleek &; Shine shampoo and conditioner. A couple ofe days later noticed a rash all over my body and my head was extremely itchy. I was broke out from head to toe Very itchy and body was burning up pretty badly. Went to the hospital I was prescribed steroids and told...

Brittani C
Customer service
1.3 (31 reviews)
1.7 (85 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...I contacted customer service who was of no help and said a manager was not available and would call me back. of course they didnt..


...Customer service made no acknowledgement to any prior issues with these products, though I have viewed many on-line. Loreal is a huge corporation that should not be allowed to put dangerous products on the market. I still have received no call back or follow up...

Katie F

Carols Daughter and Garnier Pros and Cons

  • Ive had great products delivery has the buyout changed that
  • Great product
  • Fragrance
  • Smells nice
  • Smell
  • Product is an outright rip off
  • Scalp itching
  • Tingling
  • That i spent years growing my hair to fall out
  • Ruined my hair
  • Made my hair fall out
  • Losing my hair

Carols Daughter and Garnier Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews

I've never had a problem with the products; my whole family uses various items with no issues. I placed my most recent o...


I have used Garnier products (shampoos & conditioners) for more than 10 years and like them very much.

Recently I t...

Carols Daughter and Garnier Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews

I purchased the product the product came pretty quickly as far as shipping is concern I got it for a pretty decent...


I have been using Garnier,s "Olia" hair dyes since they came on the market and just a few weeks ago i decided to try a d...

Carols Daughter and Garnier Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews

I began using Carols Daughter about 4 months ago. my hair became very dry and brittle. My hair eventually began...

Read all 98 reviews

Cannot find Garnier new Skin Active cream with Lavandin anywhere in Kingston, Ontario. Where can I buy this product?

Read all 310 reviews

Carols Daughter and Garnier Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Carols Daughter Shampoo (30 reviews)
  • Carols Daughter Hair Care (13 reviews)
  • Carols Daughter Customer Care (6 reviews)
  • Garnier Hair Dye (71 reviews)
  • Garnier Olia Hair Dye (19 reviews)
  • Garnier Shampoo (16 reviews)