Breyers vs Edys: which one is better? @ Pissed Consumer

PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Breyers and Edys as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Start a new comparison

Breyers

2.0

Edys

2.8

Breyers

Edys

Breyers and Edys Overview

Total reviews

560

184

Company responses

Issues resolved

Breyers was first mentioned on PissedConsumer on Aug 16, 2007 and since then this brand received 560 reviews. It is 376 reviews more than Edys received since May 17, 2010. According to received "Issue Resolved" consumers' votes, a consumer is more likely to resolve issues with Edys customer support team than with Breyers customer service.

Breyers and Edys Consumer Ratings

Rank

12 out of 156 in Dairy Foods category

56 out of 1016 in Food Manufacturers category

Product or Service Quality

11 in category

45 in category

Diversity of Products or Services

9 in category

44 in category

Value for money

12 in category

48 in category

Breyers and Edys Rating Details

Product or Service Quality

1.8 (162 reviews)

2.7 (59 reviews)

Reviewer's quote

Breyers Natural vanilla was my one and only all time favorite. I was disappointed when the carton size decreased (cheepo) but still loved the flavor - closest taste to home-made. No longer.... the taste and texture are gross - don't know what happened but I'm not buying it again.

Judy P

He looked so drugged and slept for almost one an/a half hour. Then woke up did not know where he was. Now awake. He feels sluggish. What are you all doing to thePEOPLE. My husband is 80 years old. He'd better turn out okay behind this ! This is terrible !

Yusuf

Diversity of Products or Services

2.5 (115 reviews)

3.3 (51 reviews)

Reviewer's quote

You’ve added so many Oreos to the cookies and cream, that there’s not even enough cream.......so over the top rich, that you can barely get a half cup serving down, without drinking a glass of water as a chaser! Come on guys, I love sweets, but this is ridiculous!

Maxine M

What have you done? Don't you make enough money? You won't be getting anymote of mine. It used to be a creamy carmel delight,NOW it's a tasteless, gritty,pathetic imposter. I was so addicted to it, it will be sorely missed.

Carol B

Value for money

1.9 (101 reviews)

3 (42 reviews)

Reviewer's quote

What happened? When did it happen? Where is My One and Only favorite flavored Breyer's Ice Cream? Ugh!I live down South on the Coast. Biloxi, Mississippi. One of my worse nightmares came true, WALMART has put Winn Dixie out of business, the place I shopped for groceries the most, especially My...

Alena C

I recently bought the new Edy's Triple Filled Creamy Chocolatey Cores. I paid $5.96 for this ice cream expecting to find 3 cores filled with fudge going from top to bottom of the ice cream after watching the commercial. After digging halfway into tje container, I found 3 hollow cores that had some...

Perrion

Breyers and Edys Pros and Cons

Pros

Old coffee flavor
Old formula
Old cherry vanilla

Slow churned ice cream
Ice cream
Half fat slow churned ice cream

Cons

Misleading packaging
Texture
Crappy fake ice cream

Unnecessary and environmentally irresponsible ingredients
New slow churned ice cream
Made me sick

Breyers and Edys Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews

My husband and I each chose our own pint of ice cream, he chose a variety from ben and jerrys, while i selected the...

My favorite flavor of all times is apple pie. The problem is, I haven't seen it the last 2 seasons. Three counting this...

Breyers and Edys Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews

Had not bought Breyers for a few years. Grew up on this brand. My mother wouldn't buy any other. Bought two 1.5...

I LOVE getting Edy's ice cream. Their flavors are always perfect and their ice cream is typically pretty well priced...

Breyers and Edys Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews

I was 3 spoons in when I bit into something very hard and there was 2 fragments. This should not have been in the...

Read all 560 reviews

He looked so drugged and slept for almost one an/a half hour. Then woke up did not know where he was. Now awake. He feel...

Read all 184 reviews

Breyers and Edys Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services

Breyers Ice Cream (250 reviews)
Breyers Frozen Dairy Dessert (42 reviews)
Breyers Butter Pecan Ice Cream (31 reviews)

Edys Ice Cream (80 reviews)
Edys Slow Churned Ice Cream (19 reviews)
Edys Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream (5 reviews)

How would you compare Breyers vs Edys?

Customer service

Product or Service Quality

I have something else to compare

I have read and agree to the Pissed Consumer Terms of Service

Share your opinion

Anonymous silversmith Sep 08, 2018 #1555741

I am not able to compare Breyers vs Edys, but I am curious as to where you came up with the name "palatable otter" as the name on your emails to me. Huh????

I prefer my real name "silversmith". SILVERSMITH

0 0