PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Breyers and Edys as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Breyers
Edys

Breyers and Edys Overview

Total reviews
581
198
Company responses
0
0
Issues resolved
1
1

Breyers and Edys Consumer Ratings

Rank
13 out of 79 in Dairy Foods category
72 out of 776 in Food Manufacturers category
Product or Service Quality
11 in category
70 in category
Diversity of Products or Services
12 in category
61 in category
Value for money
14 in category
82 in category
Advertised vs Delivered
12 in category
56 in category

Breyers and Edys Rating Details

Product or Service Quality
1.7 (172 reviews)
2.6 (66 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...How do you mess up your product that bad by forgetting an ingredient? I will stick to my usual choice of Ben and Jerry's. I would rather pay more than eat this garbage! So upset!..

Read full review

There is not a thing wrong with your product. My concern is that there is no way of knowing if its been tamper with. As Im sure you know or have seen kids going into store and posting on the internet them opening ice cream and licking the ice cream and returning to the shelf...

Read full review
Diversity of Products or Services
2.5 (120 reviews)
3.1 (59 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

Thats why I stay away from artificial hormone products. And when I call them, they wanted to send me coupons, COUPONS!!!?? I DON'T EVER WANT ANOTHER BREYERS PRODUCT, EVER!!! ANYBODY WANT TO TEST THIS BOX TO CHECK IT FOR ARTIFICIAL HORMONES!!!! COMPENSATE ME!!!! AND I WANT MORE THAN $3. 99 I PAID...

Read full review

Your company could be opening itself up to all kinds of lawsuits! Not to mention the freaks that are going around taking the tops off of ice cream products and licking the inside of it, and possibly exposing people to deadly viruses like COVID-19 or any other nasty infection or disease you can...

Read full review
Value for money
1.9 (109 reviews)
2.9 (49 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...Waste of money..

Read full review

...Ok! Back to Walmart to get my money back because should have went with ny first intuition when I was getting it to get another brand that was secured. EDYS NEEDS TO BE BAND FROM STORES. YALL LOST A FAMILYS CUSTOMER SUPPORT...

Read full review
Advertised vs Delivered
1.6 (88 reviews)
2.6 (39 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

...Not even close to what was advertised. Breyers has lost another customer. Will return the ice cream to Safeway for a refund...

Read full review

Edys strawberry pop cycles were the best full of real strawberry's &;;;;;;;;;;;; tasted like the perfect strawberry, when they 1st changed they tasted awefull but still had same packing then outshine just awefull whole fruit is the closet thing to the real edys. Please bring them back and...

Read full review

Breyers and Edys Pros and Cons

Pros
  • Old coffee flavor
  • Old formula
  • Old cherry vanilla
  • Slow churned ice cream
  • Ice cream
  • Half fat slow churned ice cream
Cons
  • Misleading packaging
  • I put all of this is my complaint
  • Texture
  • Unnecessary and environmentally irresponsible ingredients
  • New slow churned ice cream
  • Made me sick

Breyers and Edys Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews
5

My husband and I each chose our own pint of ice cream, he chose a variety from ben and jerrys, while i selected the...

Read full review
5

My favorite flavor of all times is apple pie. The problem is, I haven't seen it the last 2 seasons. Three counting this...

Read full review
5

I love this ice cream, and as far as I knew, they are the only company that still package in half gallons ...

Read full review
5

Edy's Chocolate Ice Cream has been my favorite for years now and my only complaint is that my supermarket-ShopRite in Wh...

Read full review

Breyers and Edys Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews
1

Had not bought Breyers for a few years. Grew up on this brand. My mother wouldn't buy any other. Bought two 1.5...

Read full review
1

I LOVE getting Edy's ice cream. Their flavors are always perfect and their ice cream is typically pretty well priced...

Read full review
1

I used to buy Breyers in the past 2000-2005 ... later I began buying Publix brand only (it's very good) ... but today I...

Read full review
1

I broke my tooth on pieces of small hard plastic in their ice cream. I kept chewing because I thought it was chunks of...

Read full review

Breyers and Edys Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews
1.5

We bought Breyer's 2 in 1 Oreo and Chips Ahoy ice cream. Well the side that was supposed to be Oreo ice cream was just...

Read full review
1

SToo much gumminess. Too much sugar. This ice cream is basically awful. Ive tried Eddys ice cream multiple times in...

Read full review
No votes

No response to my question

Read full review
1

Edys strawberry pop cycles were the best full of real strawberry's &;;;;;;;;;;;; tasted like the perfect...

Read full review

Breyers and Edys Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Breyers Ice Cream (254 reviews)
  • Breyers Frozen Dairy Dessert (42 reviews)
  • Breyers Butter Pecan Ice Cream (33 reviews)
  • Edys Ice Cream (86 reviews)
  • Edys Slow Churned Ice Cream (19 reviews)
  • Edys Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream (5 reviews)