PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Angies List and Service Magic as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.

Angies List
Service Magic

Angies List and Service Magic Overview

Total reviews
705
509
Company responses
0
9
Issues resolved
4
0

Angies List and Service Magic Consumer Ratings

Rank
10 out of 167 in Review Websites and Directories category
81 out of 921 in Household Services category
Customer service
7 in category
48 in category
Product or Service Quality
8 in category
239 in category
Website
10 in category
61 in category
Reliability
7 in category
41 in category

Angies List and Service Magic Rating Details

Customer service
1.4 (211 reviews)
2.6 (5 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

Tried 3 different numbers for Angie's List to try to talk to someone in customer service and they all have the most annoying voice message where it doesn't get you to a person - very unhelpful!! I won't be using Angie's List as I can't even talk to a live person about problems with their website!!...

Read full review

2009 As a start up carpet cleaning business, I started paying for leads from Service Magic and mostly, I got the run around. People who had already been called so many times by other carpet cleaners, that they didn't bother answering the phone anymore or were very irritable about talking to me? ...

Read full review
Product or Service Quality
1.6 (186 reviews)
1 (1 review)
Reviewer's quote

...getting referrals to cities that are out of agreed areas-- I have contacted them on this and it didn't stop -- They also told me it was a month-to-month service I took them on trust and now I find it is a year contract. -- I am so disgusted with their service, I feel it is another rip-off service. Don't bother using...

Read full review

No items

Website
1.7 (175 reviews)
2.6 (5 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

Since then, I have received at least three calls from other tradesmen telling me that I made a request for service via another Website. I also learned that these tradesmen are charged by this second company (Home Advisor) for leads that I did not want. Today I received still another call, this time...

Read full review

Wow, I'm really disappointed to read the complaints about this company. I was looking them up to find a service as I had used them a few times in the past and was extremely happy with the choice I made in providers. I never considered what the contractors had to deal with on their end. I would...

Read full review
Reliability
1.4 (119 reviews)
3 (2 reviews)
Reviewer's quote

Installation of gate hinges installed improperly. Slats used for the gate are unacceptable. Very dissatisfied. Called the installer many times. He returned one call and said would be out to correct. Never showed up. Not returning calls after that.

Read full review

No items

Angies List and Service Magic Pros and Cons

Pros
  • To see a variety of ratings
  • This is about angies list
  • Fairness to the customer
  • I got 2-jobs
  • Contractors i used
Cons
  • Poor customer service
  • False claims
  • Not intersted in fix
  • Jaime hernandez
  • Fake and false clients

Angies List and Service Magic Most Positive Reviews

Top rated reviews
5

Purchased a central boiler wood furance....dealer sold me the wrong underground pipe lied to me central boiler can not...

Read full review
5

On 16th May 2014, a Partner of this Company came out and took measurements of my Garden with regards to laying a Patio....

Read full review
5

I would never advise anyone to have protect America, you must give them 30 day notice to cancel and not just verbal...

Read full review
5

Wow, I'm really disappointed to read the complaints about this company. I was looking them up to find a service as I...

Read full review

Angies List and Service Magic Most Critical Reviews

Lowest rated reviews
1

Angie's list is a ripoff. The contractors you call always have someway of getting around the deals listed on angie's...

Read full review
1

Service magic pro, charge a min of 3 tradesman for each lead. They make 3 times the amount for every lead, no wonder the...

Read full review
1

Angie's list is the worst company. They have been in the red for the past 5 years(losing money) . And now it is for sale...

Read full review
1

We paid this company for referral service to introduce and send us new customer but every customer we were referred to...

Read full review

Angies List and Service Magic Latest Reviews

Recent published reviews
No votes

Hired a builder from Angie's list to do a home remodel. Initially work was good. Then when 2/3 of work was completed con...

Read full review
No votes

Still charging me and ive cancelled they are no good. Iys just like america its falling apart. Cant wait til the true...

Read full review
1

Tried creating an account to find a plumber. It said my email was invalid. Tried 3 different numbers for Angie's List...

Read full review
1

I have used service magic in the pass around 2006 thru 2008 My first 6-months was not bad but after that all downhill...

Read full review

Angies List and Service Magic Products and Services

Most reviewed product and services
  • Angies List Membership (163 reviews)
  • Angies List Website (52 reviews)
  • Angies List Customer Care (39 reviews)