Select Home Warranty vs American Home Shield
PissedConsumer.com strives to provide consumers with the right information to make informed purchasing decisions. Our website collected and compiled various consumer reviews about Select Home Warranty and American Home Shield as well as customer ratings and recommendations for these brands. Each brand score is calculated based on set of relevant criteria and displays company performance over time.
Select Home Warranty and American Home Shield Overview
Total reviews | 522 | 4671 |
Company responses | 474 | 0 |
Issues resolved | 3 | 38 |
Select Home Warranty and American Home Shield Consumer Ratings
Select Home Warranty and American Home Shield Rating Details
Select Home Warranty and American Home Shield Pros and Cons
- That i never have to deal with them again
- I thought i liked the price
- I thought i liked the price and the coverage
- Setting up original appointment
- Non
- Easy payment
- Horrible customer service
- Fraudulent company
- Deceptive practices
- Poor customer service
- Zero integrity
- Too long of wait on the phone
Select Home Warranty and American Home Shield Most Positive Reviews
Was a very easy process....Richard did a excellent job explaining my options as well as exploring all possible...
The total experience was at least 7 stars.
AHS reps were kind and very knowledgeable. The initial service tech was great....
I never imagined that Select will cost so much for my repairs. I read their Terms and it was fine as long as you know...
This *** ain't make no sense little shorty Homeslice.
Select Home Warranty and American Home Shield Most Critical Reviews
Their sales pitch is great, just hope you do not have to use their services.
These people are scammers. Very unprofess...
Called American Home Shield to service a broken garage. They sent a person out, but $75 (and two minutes) later, I was...
I purchased this appliance coverage in November 2023.
Since then I made a call to "Repair or Replace" my dishwasher. I wa...
I purchased a home warranty from this company. As soon as I moved into my home, I detected an AC leak that was damaging...
Select Home Warranty and American Home Shield Latest Reviews
Over three weeks now and no one has showed up. I want all my money back and I fix it myself..
If I get no answer, I will...
The service was every poor. It was so bad I cancelled my service contract after 10 years. I was not allowed to speak to...
No one has called regarding service on my air conditioner. It used to take 1 day to get info about the service...
I take some solace in knowing that there are others who have had a poor experience with American Home Shield.
I am NOT re...
Both suck
Product or Service Quality
Both deny almost every claim
I have something else to compare
Looking for a legit warranty company.
Both are bad. They do not make a real effort to pay the claim but choose to deny if at all possible.
Product or Service Quality
Poor.
I have something else to compare
American Home Shield would not repair our old dryer saying lint caused the motor to go bad.
However the motor was not bad and it was sealed so lint could not possibly cause the damage.I contacted the CA insurance commissioner and they ended up paying.
Very similar to Select Home Warranty. I could not recommend either.
1
AHS is 10 times better
Product or Service Quality
AHS is 10 times better
How would you compare Select Home Warranty vs American Home Shield?
SHW ZERO
AHS 2 stars
Product or Service Quality
SHW ZERO ZERO ZERO
AHS 2 Stars
Haven't been a customer of American.
Product or Service Quality
Select Home Warranty, as far as my experience goes, is a criminal organization; they promised me $125 in lieu of replacing my broken disposal - too little, unless I did all the work myself. But that was October of last year, and all I've gotten is many broken promises - THIEVES!
I never had Home Shield, so cannot compare them. But as far as Select Home Warranty, as of today, I am out $323 for having their policy three months, since they still haven't paid me the $125 they promised in lieu of fixing my garbage disposal, Crooks.