Featured on Facebook Not resolved

I ordered 1570 pieces of tile and paid in full plus delivery charges totalling $5409.After having multiple difficulties getting the tile delivered, once it was delivered it was obvious many pieces were broken.

I noted the damage on the delivery receipt as instructed by the tile company. I then took digital photos of the damaged tile. The tile company argued that there probably wasn't as much breakage as I thought and to use the tile and save the broken pieces as they may need an insurance adjustor to view them to claim against the delivery company. I repeatedly alerted the tile company that we would not have enough tile to finish the job and asked for replacement tile to be sent as there was much more than 15% breakage.

They refused and only offer to sell me more broken tile with a wait time of weeks.

I've sent multiple emails and followed their every instruction to no avail.I want either the replacement tile sent or a refund of the 21% breakage (324 tiles)

Review about: 16 X 16 Super Sealed Manganese Saltillo Tile.

Review #432870 is a subjective opinion of a user.

Reason of Review / Monetary Loss Not specified / $1111
Preferred solution Not specified

Had an Experience with Rustico Tile and Stone?

Submit review


Comment as anonymous or
Terms of Service
Post Comment
New York, New York, United States #1239331

Hi as I am legal counsel for several large Nyc construction companies.To prevent issues such as these in the future you or your company must have an inspection procedure in place before anyone signs Deivery Purchase Orders.

Your best move is to refuse delivery when your first pass test reveals damage to any purchased product. Once the product is signed for you enter a more complex situation to be reimbursed for damaged goods which will require legal counsel.

The next step is strait foreword, contact a local attorney and pursue legal action against the company.

Be prepared to provide dates, times, emails, company representative names, call logs (from your phone company) contract terms of order, photos etc for the firm before contacting.

Please pursue, don't let venting your anger online satisfy you.There is significant monetary & even business reputation loss with this case.


Oddly, the instructions I had to agree to in order to activate the freight insurance specifically said not to refuse delivery, even if the driver advised it.They said to note damage on the shipping receipt form but accept the tile.

I followed the directions, immediately contacted the company and sent photos.

I'm at a loss as to how I could have handled this better while still following their guidelines.But, I'll never order something so breakable online again.

Colorado Springs, Colorado, United States #688155

It might have been wise to refuse the shipment.However, too late now...

And yes, the company probably filed a claim and received the usual "insufficient packaging" as a response from the carrier.Sad situation, but seems that it is made worse by the company's refusal to re-ship replacement tiles.


Did you get insurance on the package? If it cost that much and knowing it would be fragile tile I would have got the insurance. How is it their fault for the mail company breaking the tiles?

to Anonymous #688113

The tile company had freight insurance and asked me to respond to an email outlining the delivery terms in order to activate the coverage which I did. There seems to be some finger pointing between the shipping company ("crates were overpacked, packed incorrectly") and the tile company. I believe this is a case where no one cares if the customer is left holding the bag as long as they can blame someone else for it.

You May Also Like

Lumber Liquidators - Bellawood Ultra-Strand Bamboo grain is fake printed junk! Lumber Liquidators "We bought Bellawood Bronze Ultra-Strand Bamboo from Lumber Liquidators. This Bellawood Bronze Ultra-Strand Bamboo is not what you think it is. While it is true that is a solid hardwood,..." Read more Review about Wolf Cabinets Hudson Cabinets from Nashua, New Hampshire Wolf Cabinets "We redid our kitchen August 2014 and chose Wolf because of price and we liked the look of the sample cabinet in the showroom. They seemed well made, but now..." Read more Stanley Tools - Stanley fatmax Stanley Tools "i am a roofing carpenter and always use the fatmax tapes. The last 3 that I Have purchased have all split, this problem has just started happening, never Had this..." Read more VersaTube - Happy Ram VersaTube "After much research, I decided to go with the Versa Tube Grand. I have read the reviews and admit I had the same issue with the free shipping, and never..." Read more Oklahoma Natural Gas made a mess ... Oklahoma Natural Gas "A guy whos truck # is 66730 came out to shut off the gas to the house next to me and made a mess of my plants ''my cactus'' and..." Read more Kitchenaid - FRIDGE IMPLOSION THREE YEARS OLD! Kitchenaid "#NOKITCHENAID from #KitchenAid... You cannot give us a peace of mind warranty on our three year old non-working fridge because... and I quote; "age of the unit!" Yet, we can..." Read more Oberto Sausage Company - Extensive Molds in Unopened Beef Jerky Package and 8 Months Before "Best By" Date Oberto Sausage Company "I had purchased a package of Oberto Original Beef Jerky 10 oz from amazon last year, received sealed and unopened, with a "Best By 05Jan18" date. On April 18, 2017,..." Read more Skillshare automatically charged me  $96 for a yearly memebership when my three month  99 cent trial  expired.  I informed them a few days prior on their online page that I did not want it renewed. Skillshare "It all happened today. They put through the charge for the membership today. I informed them I wanted to cancel the memebership. I got an email from them that my..." Read more