Skip to content

Contact Penzeys Spices Customer Service

How to Reach a Person at Penzeys Spices

Verified Contact Information

Toll-Free Number:

  • 1-800-741-7787
Call customer service
Send Message

Customer Service:

  • 1-414-882-8752
  • 1-414-760-7337

Penzeys Spices Emails:

Accessibility
Complaints/ Feedback
Customer Service
Orders, Store Location Suggestion
Legal
Privacy Inquiries
Technical Support

Penzeys Spices Customer Service Overview

The aggregated data is based on calls made from PissedConsumer.com website and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.

Most Popular Penzeys Spices Phone Number
1 (800) 741-7787
Average Hold Time
Less than 1 minute
Average Calls duration
1 minute
Most Popular Penzeys Spices Email Address
myorder@penzeys.com
Issue Resolution Rate
Low (30% reported full resolution)
Penzeys Spices Customer Service Rating
5 out of 5
Call Volume by Day
sun
mon
tue
wed
thu
fri
sat
View full overview ›

How to Contact Penzeys Spices?

Most Popular Number:

(800) 741-7787
Total calls: 24 Issues resolved: 2 Last call: Dec 23, 2025

Penzeys Spices customer service phone number is (800) 741-7787. Call this line if you have general questions about spices and recipes and need to address other consumer inquiries. You can also call this umber if you want to share your experience about visiting one of the corporate stores.
If you choose to contact the company by phone, avoid calling Penzeys Spices support on Wednesday as this is the busiest day of the week.

Penzeys Spices email address is customerservice@penzeys.com. If you have questions about your order, drop a line at myorder@penzeys.com. If you have issues navigating the Penzeys Spices website, send a message to accessibility@penzeys.com while the corporate tech team can be reached at tech@penzeys.com.
If you want to share your experience with the company and submit a complaint or feedback, shoot a note at mystorevisit@penzeys.com.

The corporate office is based in Wisconsin. Penzeys Spices address is 12001 W. Capitol Drive, Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53222, United States. If you need to get in touch with the company offline, feel free to direct your correspondence to the main office.

Penzeys Spices call center operates Monday through Friday from 8 am to 5 pm CST. On Saturday, support agents are available between 9 am and 3 pm CST. Penzeys Spices support team also operates on Sundays from 11 am to 4 pm CST. Please note that the usual hours of operation can be affected by holidays.

Penzeys Spices website doesn’t have an option of reaching out to the customer care department. However, you can get in touch with the support team via email or phone. To see the full list of Penzeys Spices contact details please go to the “Contact Us” page of the company’s website.

PissedConsumer Club

Contact Information

Penzeys Spices Website:

Penzeys Spices Help Center:

Corporate Office Address:

Penzeys Spices
12001 W. Capitol Drive
Wauwatosa, Wisconsin 53222
United States

Other Info (opening hours):

Hours (CST):

Monday - Friday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Saturday: 9:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Sunday: 11:00 AM - 4:00 PM

More contact details

Summary of Penzeys Spices Customer Service Calls

33 TOTAL
CALLS
00:56 AVG CALL
DURATION
30% ISSUES
RESOLVED

Top Reasons of Customers Calls

Consumers Call the Most From

Why Do People Call Penzeys Spices?

Request for Information Question:

  • “Request a catalog”
  • “Place order”

Cards Question:

  • “My gift card is not working”
  • “Lost gift card”

Product/ Service Question:

  • “Working at the warehouse in Wauwatosa part time .my work schedule. form to put in my hours for the week of December 9th was never sent to my phone for filling out. please send that out as soon as possible.”
  • “Order assistance”

Return/ Replace Question:

  • “Return needed”
  • “Buy products/trouble changing password”

Shipping and Delivery Question:

  • “Shipping?”

Other Question:

  • “Ordering problem”
  • “Need catalig”
  • “Need spice catalog asap”

Compare Penzeys Spices Customer Service To

Companies are selected automatically by the algorithm. A company's rating is calculated using a mathematical algorithm that evaluates the information in your profile. The algorithm parameters are: user's rating, number of resolved issues, number of company's responses etc. The algorithm is subject to change in future.

Frequently Asked Questions

PissedConsumer collects contact information primarily from official companies' channels, such as corporate websites and verified social media pages. Data from these sources is usually added without additional individual verification. If the contact comes from a secondary source, the PissedConsumer team verifies it against fraud and abuse reporting databases and conducts additional validation, including test calls, prior to publication. We also perform regular, selective spot checks and respond promptly to users' reports and requests to ensure the data is current, accurate, and secure.

Phone numbers published on the official company website or its verified social media pages are considered authoritative at the time of the information collection. For contacts obtained from secondary sources, the PissedConsumer team conducts risk screening and additional validation before publication. We also promptly verify any phone numbers reported by the community and remove records that fail to pass verification or update their status.
Contact information posted by users in comments and reviews is not verified by PissedConsumer and may be unreliable. We suggest relying primarily on the official contact details in the company profile and reporting any suspicious content through the reporting form for your safety. Also, note that the phone numbers shown in the ads are not associated with the company's official contact details.

The PissedConsumer team always maintains the accuracy of contact details and reverifies phone numbers and email addresses of the companies. We prioritize reverifying data reported by our users and data that shows warning signs. Besides, we quickly check phone numbers that seem disconnected, reassigned, or compromised. Our team also promptly updates and cross-checks data when verified company representatives report discrepancies in contact details. However, please note that we do not guarantee fixed intervals for revalidating every listing.

The primary sources for the contact information listed here are official company sources, such as their corporate website and verified social media profiles. The PissedConsumer team also uses direct data from the company or its authorized representatives when possible.

PissedConsumer does not publish unverified contact information. We mainly rely on official company websites and their verified social media pages. They are regarded as authoritative sources. Our team cross-checks every update and conducts thorough risk screening. Whenever possible, we use contact details that companies or their official representatives give us. If so, everything stays current. If customers or businesses report incorrect contact information, we start a validation process and cross-reference the details with trusted third-party sources.

Names, phone numbers, and email addresses listed on this page are provided for informational purposes and to help you contact the company. We check and believe this information is accurate, but because details can change, PissedConsumer.com does not guarantee notice any incorrect contact details, you can report them by filling out this form.

Write a review
Do you have something to say about Penzeys Spices? What happened? What can we help you with?
Submit review Don't show this popup