Etrade - Crazy trading logic, poor customer service

50 of 121 Etrade reviews

I had purchased 1,000 shares of AGNC early in 2012; the purchase was made in two consecutive blocks of 700 and 300. Through dividends reinvestment I purchase two more blocks of shares, 3 months apart, 40.57307 and 35.20234.

I decided to sell the 2 'DRIP' blocks and when I completed the transaction a note informed me that "the fractional shares" would be sold on a FIFO basis.

I looked back into my account to find 4 blocks of stock!: 699.22459, 300, 0.57307 and 0.20234.

They didn't sell the fractional shares, the took the sum total of the fractional shares, deducted them from a whole share, thus creating another block with a fractional share! They claim that fractional shares are sold on a FIFO basis. OK, fine, but they didn't sell the fractional shares, they sold the equivalent of the fractional shares from a whole share.

I opened a support request on this and was told this is how they sell fractional shares. I asked to escalate this and was told it was not possible. I told the rep I was going to close my account for this and list her name and refusal to escalate this for correction as one of the reasons for the closure.

Next, I get a call from an eTrade rep who wants to discuss my earlier phone call; she asks for my account info and SSN!!! Really, I'm supposed to provide personal, secure account info over the phone to someone who called me?!!! I told her I'd have to call her before providing any such information.

Consolidating my accounts into Schwab where when they tell you "the fractional share" are going to be sold, the sell "THE" fractional shares and not the equivalent of the fractional shares on a FIFO basis.

This review is a subjective opinion of a user.
Report Comment

More Review Details

Review category
Financial Services
review #378358
Had an experience with Etrade? Submit review ›
Helpful? 2 Yes 2 7 No 7
Had the same issue 0 Yes 0
50 of 121 Etrade reviews
Burt Dingman

May 23, 2013 #655144 Stone Mountain, Georgia, United States

You aren't not very bright. It's so funny to read these reviews. A bunch of morons who have no idea how all this "works" crying foul.

2 1 Reply
Great comment! Would you like to convert it into review?

You will be able to edit the text before publishing.

You May Also Like

You were reading a complaint about Etrade.
Filing a new complaint about