Butterfinger
Butterfinger Overview
The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
Butterfinger has a 2.7 star rating from 4 reviews; consumers are mostly neutral and 100% would likely recommend.
Positive Feedback
Customers praise appearance and occasional new varieties like marshmallow coating, and reviewers value the Website and Discounts and Special Offers despite a high price level.
Negative Feedback / Risk Areas
- Many Butterfinger customer complaints focus on awful or changed taste and dislike of the new recipe.
- Reports of hard, stale bars and improperly sealed or damaged packaging.
- Seasonal discontinuations frustrate fans wanting year-round availability.
Key Takeaways for Future Customers
- Read Butterfinger reviews and check expiration dates before buying.
- Use the brand website for discounts and contact customer service for refunds or damaged items.
- Consider alternative products if you dislike the new recipe.
The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.
Butterfinger has a 2.7 star rating from 4 reviews; consumers are mostly neutral and 100% would likely recommend.
Positive Feedback
Customers praise appearance and occasional new varieties like marshmallow coating, and reviewers value the Website and Discounts and Special Offers despite a high price level.
Negative Feedback / Risk Areas
- Many Butterfinger customer complaints focus on awful or changed taste and dislike of the new recipe.
- Reports of hard, stale bars and improperly sealed or damaged packaging.
- Seasonal discontinuations frustrate fans wanting year-round availability.
Key Takeaways for Future Customers
- Read Butterfinger reviews and check expiration dates before buying.
- Use the brand website for discounts and contact customer service for refunds or damaged items.
- Consider alternative products if you dislike the new recipe.
Media from reviews
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer
Amazing Butterfinger with marshmallows coating
The new marshmallow butterfinger is really good although it tastes more like white chocolate I think they should add a little more of the marshmallows to it. But its definitely good and should become a regular.
Have spoken with many that love it! Just wish more stores carried it I had checked over 20 stores that didnt have it!
Port Washington, Wisconsin
Damaged Bags of Butterfingers
Our family purchases three bags of the jumbo butterfingers weekly. Two of the three bags were not sealed properly, wrappers not cut and open ended, sticky in goo inside the bag.
My husband threw out the bags.
However I successfully retrieved one and this is the lot number. L029KDA-MH Best by date September 11 2025
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified Reviewer |
Munster, Indiana
ANGRY
The one thing I wait on all year because they have the audacity to only make at Easter, then they discontinue making, are the nest eggs. Please, please bring them back and not only at Easter.
How about Christmas, Valentine's Day, or any other holiday? We are definitely begging to bring them back year-round, PLEASE!!!
Preferred solution: I would Definitely be grateful if they would bring the nesteggs back and not only at Easter how about all year long. PLEASE!!!!! Like NOW?? The only kind of candy I LOVE!!! Now I can't get them!!!!
So far I have opened 1 and my husband has opened one and they are so hard you could use a hammer to break threm up.
Make sure that there are always fresh Butterfingers. Nothing is better than to bite into a fresh Butterfinger and have it all break apart in your mouth. Your taste buds celebrate the exciting flavor that keeps popping up the entire time you eat your candy bar down to the last crumb.
User's recommendation: check the expiration date the one i just had a bad experience with exp date of March 17, 2025
Poor quality of double packed butterfinger candy bars.
The last 4 times that I purchased double packed butterfinger candy bars over a period of 2 months I had to throw them away because they were hard as brick bats.BU
User's recommendation: Use caution when buying and do not purchase if the product is obviously old.
This review is from a real person who provided valid contact information and hasn't been caught misusing, spamming or abusing our website. Check our FAQ
Verified ReviewerTHE NEW BUTTERFINGER IS AWFUL
I'm 70+ years old and have eaten more than my weight in Butterfingers ever since they first came out.BUT YOU RUINED A WONDERFULLY DIFFERENT CANDY BAR by making it taste just like any other peanut butter candy. Instead of being my favorite bar now I HATE THEM.
Why not create an original recipe to offer too.
Otherwise if I want choc. & PB, I'LL JUST BUY A REESE CUP!!!
- Great appearance
- Yuck
- Awful taste
Preferred solution: Bars made from old recipe offered to buy!
User's recommendation: Buy Reese Cups!!!!!
Mesa, Arizona
New recipe is horribly disgusting
The new recipe is so disgusting! everyone Ive asked hates it and wont even buy them anymore, I dont know why they would change it so dramatically..
it tastes nothing like the original and now its nothing special, just bad tasting peanut butter with chocolate, I cant even comprehend whos buying these gross things.. Im done buying them unless they change it back.
Preferred solution: Let the company propose a solution
User's recommendation: Don’t buy these gross things
Nestle added peanut butter to an already delicious candy bar.
The addition of peanut butter to the flavor of the original
butterfinger candy bar, in my estimation, has ruined the taste of my favorite snack. If they felt that adding peanut butter to this delicious bar was a wise choice, then they should have at least kept the original bar available to those of us who prefer the original or who cannot eat it due to the addition of peanuts. I wonder if they tested it out on it consumers before doing away with the original taste.
Waldorf, Maryland
You call the new recipe Butterfinger "improved"??
Another greedy company looking to increase profits has ruined another once great American brand
Butterfinger candy bars
Why why did u change the product???
It is disgusting and used to be my favorite candy bar!!!
Please share why u felt u had to change the product!!!
I wud like a refund please on the last box i will ever buy!!
- We sell great only
Preferred solution: Full refund
Bonney Lake, Washington
New butterfinger recipe?
What the heck did you do to my favorite candy bar in the world!!!
my husband and I sat down, while camping, to enjoy our long awaited treat for the day.
The flavor changed some how, used to get that intense peanut butter flavor, with chewy, and at the same time crunchy middle that I used to enjoy. Also doesn't seem to be as sweet as it used to be.
Wish you hadn't changed the perfect blend. Cathy Nelson
Brands Related to Butterfinger
Keebler
“I was eating a keebler, Vienna finger cookie yesterday 11/18/25 morning and I found a what I thought was...“
Ferrero Rocher
“When I opens the rappers there was mold on them and I wanted to enjoy some chocolate but when there is...“
Brachs
“I would like to speak with someone about these tasteless mini peppermint sticks I bought at Walmart....“
Ferrara Candy Company
“I wanted to buy things, i picked them out but there was no place to take my money very disorganized in...“
Companies Similar to Butterfinger
Wrigley
“No one answer the call. I bought a jumbo bag of Twix fun size and inside there is a bunch of fun size...“
Swedish Fish
“I was enjoying a box of Swedish fish when I bid into one it tasted very hot like it had some sort of...“
Popcorn Indiana
“The customer service person said they would send an email to the person that may be able to address a...“
Mikes Hard Lemonade Co
“I would like to know why you stopped making the mikes cranberry lemonade in the 6pk bottles. I have been...“
Thank You for Your Reply! We are processing your message.
Your comment is successfully posted.