Skip to content
Blackfinn

Blackfinn Reviews

www.blackfinndc.com
What is your customer experience with Blackfinn?

Blackfinn Overview

The generated data is based on reviews and questionnaires provided by PissedConsumer.com users.

AI insights based on reviews
Rating Distribution

Blackfinn has a 1.3 star rating from 3 reviews and overall customer sentiment is negative, citing poor customer service, high price level, limited product/service diversity, and website issues noted in Blackfinn reviews.

Positive Feedback

Some patrons praised appetizers and occasional good food, but positive mentions are rare in overall Blackfinn customer feedback.

Negative Feedback / Risk Areas

  • Repeated customer service failures, including hung up calls and no corporate refunds for gift card closures.
  • Serious safety and staff conduct complaints, including withholding information and disrespectful management.
  • Food quality concerns such as alleged food poisoning and long service delays.

Key Takeaways for Future Customers

  • Expect to research Blackfinn customer complaints and ask about refunds or gift card policies before purchasing.
  • Confirm reservation and management communication; consider alternatives if price sensitivity or safety concerns matter.
View full overview ›

Media from reviews

Blackfinn - Food poisoning
View all media ›

Turn one complaint into a collective action

PC collective complaint

A Collective Complaint helps you unite consumers dealing with the same issue, such as wrong charges, unexpected fees, damaged items, or misleading promises. It goes beyond a single review by growing stronger with every signature, making it harder to ignore. Once you reach 20 supporters, we’ll send it to the company to encourage a response.

Start Collective Complaint
Show reviews that mention
gift card service manager food people restaurant card gift refund peter donahue
Filter review
Sort by
Anonymous

Gift card refund

AI Highlights
  • - Local store went out of business.
  • - They refused a refund for my card and said there is no corporate line.
  • - Customer service was poor.

Our local store went out of business I called the corporate line they said there is no corporate line and were refusing to give me a refund for my card. This business sucks and their customer service is poor.

They gave me a line of BS! I would never ever support this company

Loss:
$50
Reason of review:
Poor customer service

Preferred solution: Full refund

View full review
Jodie C Dmv

Terribly disrespectful to veterans

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Owner Peter Donahue scheduled a 4:00 interview; he did not appear.
  • - Customer waited 30 minutes; no contact, email sent 4:30; no reply by 6:30.

Talk about a disrespectful restaurant!! I have been in restaurant Management for 20 years and have NEVER experienced the disrespect that I did from Blackfinn today.

The Owner Operator Peter Donahue set up Management interview at 4 pm today with me. I arrived 10 minutes ahead of the appt and found no one at the host stand when I arrived. After about 5 mins a server appeared to tell me that Peter wasn’t there. I assumed he was running late.

I was seated and given a glass of water. Our appt was from 4-4:30. I sat at the table from 4-4:30 and Peter Donahue never showed up, no call, no text, no nothing. Incredibly disrespectful to have someone sit there for 30 minutes.

I could tell the staff was VERY uncomfortable with him leaving me there. Sent an email to Peter Donahue at 4:30 and as of 6:30, 2 full hours after our appt, still no response, wow! How do I feel as a US Veteran? Is my time not as valuable as Peter Donahoe’s??

One can only wonders how they treat the customers/employees here, not good.

I HIGHLY RECOMMEND that you spend your money ELSEWHERE at a restaurant where employees and interviewees are treated with dignity and respect. BLACKFINN ASHBURN is NOT that restaurant!!!

Reason of review:
Work Experience or Job Application
View full review
2 comments
Guest

So you got stood up for a job interview by the owner.. that sucks and would have made me very angry too.. but, what does you being a veteran have to do with anything?

Guest

Veteran or not. No difference. Rude is an equal opportunity jerk.

View more comments (1)
Drayven Mzo

Food poisoning

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - Valentine's Day 2018 at Blackfinn: greasy fish.
  • - Illness: vomiting; sick for 3 days.
  • - Refund issues: partial refund; taxes not returned; gift card not received.
Blackfinn - Food poisoning

On Valentine's Day. February 14th 2018 me and my girlfriend dying at Blackfinn in Mount Prospect Illinois.

I ordered some fried fish and my girlfriend ordered some baked fish. The fish was so greasy I had to soak some grease out on some napkins. So I start eating my fried fish 5 minutes into eating my stomach started feeling a little funny. So I continue to eat and my stomach got worse.

So around 1:53 a.m. the next day I started vomiting/throwing up. I was sick for 3 days. I call Blackfinn the next day and told them about my problem.

They gave me the run-around and a week later I had to call them back again they said that they would refund my whole purchase but I only receive a refund on one order and they didn't even give me my taxes back on that. They also said that they will send me a gift card it's been almost two weeks now and I still haven't received it.

I spoke with the manager and he was very disrespectful and rude over the phone. I still would like my refund and my gift card.

Reason of review:
Bad quality
View full review
4 comments
Guest

Actual food poisoning kicks in about 15 mins of the first bite. It sounds like a bile issue which kinda feels like food poisoning.

It’s too much bile versus how much grease/fat that is sitting in your stomach. Inevitably your bodies response is to expel it instead of digest. That is not food poisoning. That is the response your body had to greasy fish.

Also as the previous person posted, without definitive evidence from a medical lab/hospital then your claim of food poisoning is suspect. Then you not only want to eat the food then call up and whine about it but you want to eat there again by using their gift card.

It really sounds like you want something for free and when you didn’t get it you go on PC and embellish the situation. Because of these facts that you have posted is what makes you suspect.

Guest

Unless you sought medical attention and they ran the necessary tests, you have NO proof you had food poisoning and it was caused by the meal from Blackfinn. And if you did indeed have food poisoning, what person would wantto go back with a gift card? Very suspect story.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1438478

Lol i wasn't going back there never and i do have proof that i went to the emergency room.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1438478

I should have known something what's wrong when there wasn't really no one in the restaurant on Valentine's Day.

View more comments (3)
Makeisha Oxl
map-marker Montgomery, Alabama

Gift card

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full

Called customer service. Was hung up on. Want a refund for a gift card i cant use now that the Montgomery alabama restaurant was closed.

Reason of review:
Return, Exchange or Cancellation Policy
View full review
Conrado Zjo
map-marker Vienna, Virginia

Assault victim

AI Highlights
  • - I was assaulted by a mob outside Blackfinn Merrifield, VA.
  • - Staff withheld information from police that night.
  • - They shared it with me the next morning.

I was assaulted by a number of people outside of Blackfinn Merrifield, VA. The staff withheld information from the police that night, which they shared with me the next morning.

They knowingly withheld information on a mob assault on a ongoing case where many staff members witnessed the event.

View full review
Anonymous
map-marker Beaumont, Texas

Very disappointing experience on 9/26/15 at Austin location

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
AI Highlights
  • - 9/26/15 reservation for 9; poor table and slow service; two steaks ruined, glass in a beer; next day, North Italian offered good service and food.

Family birthday celebration was terrible. We had reservations on 9/26/15 for 9 people and got the worst table, unable to watch any of the football games.

The hostess absolutely refused to help change our table, even though there were other tables and space to do so. Good appetizers, we ordered a variety. However, poor entrees. 2 ruined steaks, glass shard in someone's beer.

2 plus hours to get through the ordeal. I do not plan on a return visit. Fortunately, there are other good places to eat at The Domain in Austin.

The next day we redeemed our birthday meal to celebrate mom's 74th at North Italian restaurant. They treated us right, awesome service and food.

Cons:
  • Food preparation
  • Customer service
Reason of review:
Bad quality

Preferred solution: Let the company propose a solution

View full review
Ruther Tjk

July 4, 2011

AI Highlights
  • - Customer says they spoke with GM James Faller about a July 4 incident.
  • - They dispute the GM's account and note online complaints about BlackFinn.

BlackFinn,

Here, I am placing a complaint about an establishment and understanding that little will be done unless someone speaks out.

Will I am speaking out, I just had a conversation with the General Manager, James Faller , I listen to what He says his employee said happen on the 4th of July. Why do people lie? This guy is such a BIG LIAR . If what he says occurred there that night, charges would have been filed upon the person arrested. Who wants to go on with the particulars. Just know that Blackfinn is full of bull-***. Just look up all the complaints on the internet about Blackfinn. Why doesn't Addison do something about it?

Loss:
$210
View full review
Camisha M

BlackFinn in Arlington, TX is Horrible

AI Highlights
  • - Very slow service; multiple waiters failed to assist.
  • - Kitchen closed after taking a drink order; customers were asked to leave.

Horrible service, took hour and a half to get service. The place was not even packed, there was only 4 tables seated out of about 20 and we asked 4 different waiters for assistance on several occasions, only to be told, they would find our waiter.

We finally get someone to take our order for drinks and someone else comes to take a food order but then mentions that the kitchen is now closed.

We send our drinks back and got kicked out for making a complaint to the manager or someone pretending to be the manager. Even the cop and the bouncers said the guy was a ***!

View full review
1 comment
Guest

Overcharged my credit card (too much tip taken probably). I spoke with the "Manager", who did nothing.

I emailed the General Manager, which did nothing. Avoid at all costs. Filing complaints with every agency I can think of.

BBB gives them an F for failing to respond. Sounds familiar.

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article