Ozell Mhc

Fake coral ring sold on EBay

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
Updated by user Jan 12, 2017

Per examination by certified gemologist, the coral in the ring and described in the listing is not coral. The seller refuses returns. The seller's feedback includes negative reviews for fake items

Original review Jan 11, 2017

Az Native American Treasures also known as sedonaturquoisegirls on EBay ( 5050 ) describes itself as a mother/daughter Choctaw team making handmade jewelry in Arizona. They listed a ring on EBay as Coral, described it in the listing as Coral, and in Item Specifics Main Stone: Coral.

Having discussed the piece of jewelry with a Native American jewelry dealer, I examined the stone under a lighted magnifying glass and was convinced that it is not coral. It has NO characteristics of coral such as uneven surface and colors and shapes under magnification. I contacted the seller: “This ring just doesn't look like the other coral i have. It is such a bright red and so shiny whereas the other coral i have is much duller.

this one almost looks ceramic. i am taking it to a registered gemologist in San Antonio, TX for his opinion. If it is not real coral, I will want to return the item. Just giving you advance notification.” The seller responded : “You can take it to wherever you want but I'm telling you it's coral there's different types of color of coral there's even black coral I am so sorry we don't do refunds” The certified gemologist examined the stone under a microscope and confirmed it as fake.

There have been several negative reviews on EBay for this team selling items that are fake.

Beware! Read the negative feedback before making a purchase from this seller.

View full review
  • That they sold an item as coral when it is fake
Reason of review:
Not as described/ advertised

Preferred solution: Full refund

Annamae Eem

Absolutely ridiculous! This customer is still in possession of a genuine Red Mediterranean Coral red ring, a full refund from EBay..

a credit from PayPal...

Plus a credit from her credit card company??!!??

We do not accept returns for sanitary purposes... clearly stated on our site.

Ozell Mhc
reply icon Replying to comment of Annamae Eem

Gemologist findings:

 He is a registered jeweler with the American Gem Society, member of the prestigious American Gem Society (AGS), who adheres to that organization’s high standards for knowledge, professionalism and integrity. He is also a member of the following organizations:  Gemological Institute of America (GIA)  National Association of Jewelry Appraisers  Jewelers of America  Jewelers Security Alliance  Texas Jewelers Association

He examined the ring under a microscope, confirmed that it was not coral, that it showed none of the uneven features of coral which is a skeleton of a once living creature.

In addition, he pierced the setting with a needle. The material was soft enough to be easily penetrated, a condition that would not be there were the stone actually coral.

I also examined this piece as well as all my other coral pieces under lighted magnification and confirmed that this piece is not coral. It is an even glossy color and structure. There are no striations, rings, pores, uneven surfaces, occlusions, signs of growth structure or patterns of any kind in this stone.

Documentation from the internet re identification of fake coral: “Coral Small, sedentary marine animal,…..

characterized by a skeleton of *** or calcareous material.” (http://www.answers.com/Q/What_are_some_characteristics_of_coral) “Genuine coral will have growth rings and predominantly even coloring throughout…. Plastic imitations will have even coloring but no growth rings”. …. According to O'Donoghue (after Webster) the most certain test for the corallium varieties is longitudinal striations with regularly spaced 'pin-***' holes that are not found in the reef-building white corals.

Nor are they found in plastic. The best tools are a microscope and good lighting. … Examination under a good microscope and with back lighting should reveal some signs of coral growth structure if it is coral. Other likely alternatives are plastic or glass … The only certain way to sort out corallium rubrum is to know its structure and look for it under magnification with a good light.

… When cut and polished, the only certain method of identification is by microscopic examination to spot the tell-tale growth patterns and pores in the structure” (http://www.mindat.org/mesg-11-29****.html Genuine red coral or fake?) o “Precious corals or red corals are called corallium rubrum….. A coral, unlike most other gemstones is actually the skeletal remains of marine polyps. …It is mainly opaque and may have some surface markings that are clearly seen. Some of the most common surface markings on a coral are the wood grain effect, groove pits and striations… The main distinguishing factor between fake, synthetic and natural coral is the distinct wood grain effect that the natural ones display.

This effect is absent in its synthetic counterpart or fake coral. Fake red coral also tends to have an artificial richness in color.” (http://www.gehnabazaar.com/gemstones/34/coral.html)

These are exact quotes (SIC) from E-Bay buyer feedback  Worst Experience Ever ! Poorly Made,Returned item,Had to File case to get my $  “this is not native american made. this is a fake!”  “Not all were carved from Gemstones / Stone or Authentic”  “You are using the exact same FITISH on your bracelets THAT you got fromme,REALLY”  “WORST EXPERIENCE EVER,VINDICTIVE SELLERS,I WONT BE BACK”  “these are *** plastic and damaged and won't give refund I sent them back” The item does remain in my possession, unworn so certainly not compromised hygienically.

I contacted the seller prior to her mailing the item to me requesting cancellation of the sale. The seller refused. I contacted her again upon receipt of the item requesting return/refund. The seller refused.

I contacted the seller after consult with one jeweler and prior to consult with the second. I will be happy to return the item. I don't want it and would not wear it. Ebay representatives advised me to contact my credit card after they denied a refund.

I have seen no documentation of a refund from PayPal or my credit card. I did receive a "courtesy" refund from Ebay after contacting Ebay's CEO.

reply icon Replying to comment of Ozell Mhc

Going forward please consider contacting the seller directly prior to attempting to tarnish their reputation. Its just simply bad karma.

We are SMALL ARTISTS! This means, every dollar we have, goes into our work. Hours after hours of creating something we hope someone will love.... literally blood, sweat, tears, dreams, dollars and everything else in life goes into every single piece of jewelry we create..

even the pieces we don't create because we buy those from.. guess who... small artists who need us to support them!

Look, sorry you disagree with our description...

but we stand by it 100%!

What hurts us more... is that you decided to take it a public forum.. were not Walmart!

We are artists!

I will leave you with this...

"Art is not always about pretty things. Its about who we are, what happened to us, and how our lives are affected" - that's art. But know this...

your critical, ridiculous, and self serving ways.. always come full circle.

Annamae Eem

I would LOVE to see the "Certified Gemologist" report and ertifiec stamped finding... the item you purchased is 100% coral!

Im concerned because not only do you STILL have our product, but you also filed a dispute with your credit card company AFTER you received full credit from eBay (oh yeah, I have the proof) so let's recap... you have a Genuine Coral Ring, credit from your credit card company and then yet ANOTHER credit from eBay! So who's the "scammer" here? I urge you to email me so we can get this rectified asap.

Before we file a lawsuit against the original author of the report for defamation, business disparagement, false light, or any other claim that is legally appropriate.

Truth is, you going out of your way to damage businesses and small artists such as myself will not be tolerated!

You have received multiple credits... why do this?

Please respond or I am taking action.

Thank you


Annamae Eem

We also have over 5000 items sold with only 3 negative comments. 1 being this person and the other 2 are from the same person with duplicate eBay accounts who is currently under investigation for breaking eBay's policies and having duplicate accounts.

Yes, please check out our feedback..

Over 5000 people can't be wrong! ❤

Annamae Eem

We are artists who create and sell unique hand crafted items. We absolutely stand by our items 100% we describe the materials used to 100% accuracy.

We do not offer any returns or exchanges for sanitation reasons as previously sold items can not be re-sold to another person. The consumer who listed this complaint originally contacted us saying she "didn't like" the Ring and wanted a refund. We stated our policies that it can't be resold now that you have worn it. She then contacted us saying "the coral was fake" which it is not!

It was purchased by us from a Native American Silversmith Artist who is very well known and does amazing work. The artist has done very reputable work for us and many other artist for years. eBay ended up providing this customer a "coupon credit" for a ONE TIME "buyers remorse" which eBay credited her not us. So the customer has our item and her money back.

Normally we handle all customer issues in house and never have issues. Unfortunately, this customer just didn't like her item and because we are so small of a business we can't re-sell returned items..

its unsanitary and bad karma to pass someone else's energy onto a new buyer.

Should anyone else ever have an issue with our pieces or our business we urge you to reach out to us at sedonaturquoisegirls@***.com or aznativeamerivantreasures@***.com

And we will do our best to rectify all situations right away!


Sedona Turquoise Girls

View more comments (5)

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article