Leigh T Qyh

Confusing Accusations

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
All of the negative reviews are hard to believe. Suzanne helped us relocate from GA back in 2015. She was very helpful to us and very kind. She gave us all of the info we needed to navigate the area and the home was in pristine condition. We have nothing but good to say about her as she was our first contact with anyone in the area before and during our move. She was always willing to answer questions &;;;;;;;;; the process of getting into the home was seamless. We arrived late at night and I will never forget pulling up to all of the exterior lights on and everything waiting for us
View full review
Reason of review:
Good customer service
FRANK S Sgw

5 STARS online (VERIFIED WITH LINKS) - please read

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
Anns Rentals - 5 STARS online (VERIFIED WITH LINKS) - please read
1st of all if you look up that name their are hundreds of the same name person...this person your talking about tried everything in her power to show evidence of the several names doing the same type of business including a WARRANT out of Sarasota for this other same named person...she did the easy part. Switched to an online booking site and has 5 STAR REVIEWS...which I did the research myself as she gave me all the links...and 5 STARS NOT FROM ONE PERSON...from over 300 reviews that have stayed with her rentals...SO WHO-EVER IS THE DUMMY...repeating the same old story get your facts straight before posting bad stuff about any business or person you wouldn't want it done to you!! Every business no matter if hotel, restaurant, mom-pop, etc is going to have one happy customer this is the normal...the smart business owner fixes and corrects...but it seems like you have maybe one or two that are harsh not only to this person over/over. They are like this to many other businesses that is why I always do my research well and then get my own option….PEACE AND LOVE TO ALL IN LIFE....GOD BLESS
View full review
Cons:
  • Leaving to go home was the sad part
Reason of review:
Good customer service
Anonymous

Punta Madyn Avenue

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
I stayed at home on Punta Madryn Avenue and there were no roaches or bugs. I'm not sure if we are talking about same house here? The house was very nice and updated, with many extras features that other rentals usually don't have that I rented with before. I didn't get my security back for two weeks, which I thought I would get back right away after checking out. I did get it back though. They do have a strict policy on there rentals and maybe that's why you lost your security deposit. If you can't follow the home owner's rules or rental agreement, then maybe you should go stay at a motel?
View full review
Reason of review:
Good customer service
2 comments
Guest

MCCARTHY ROBERT A & SUZANNE21053 MIDWAY BLVDPORT CHARLOTTE, FL 33952MCCARTHY SUZANNE25257 PUNTA MADRYN AVEPUNTA GORDA, FL 33983 DONT RENT FROM HER YOU WONT GET YOUR MONEY BACK BOTH HOMES HAVE ROACHES AND SHE HAS CAMS IN THE HOME SHE CAN SEE AND HEAR YOU HOMES ARE DIRTY!!

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1460188

You are correct. These people are scammers and thieves. Stay away at all costs!

View more comments (1)
Halei Xax
map-marker Miami, Florida

Anns Rentals Property Rental Review from Miami, Florida

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
I like to do research before I rent a house. I seen all the bad reviews with this rental. I talk to Eddy over the phone and he assured me that I have nothing to be worried about. I booked two weeks with a small security deposit. I had a wonderful time with my family at this punta madryn location. I would advise everyone to not to take all the bad reviews so seriously. The house had a kitchen, and one of the reviews said it didn't. Someone even posted pictures of the fabulous kitchen.
View full review
Reason of review:
Good quality
2 comments
Guest

DO NOT RENT ANYTHING FROM HER. SHE IS A SCAM LOOK UP SUZANNE MCCARTHY ON THE CHARLOTTE COUNTY TAX THESE HOMES ARE FULL OF ROACHES SHE WILL TAKE YOUR MONEY THEN COME UP WITH SOME OTHER BS TO GET MORE MONEY SHE ALSO HAS CAMS IN THE HOMES AND SHE WILL NOT RETURN ANY DEPOSIT WHEN YOU SEE THE WORD FAB LOL THATS HER RUN

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1221158

Which home? Berwin?

View more comments (1)
Anonymous
map-marker Hope Mills, North Carolina

Airbnb Listings in Punta Gorda area under the name Erdal

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
Unfortunately, I came across this thread too late or perhaps it was just in time! After a somewhat pleasant experience of renting the property of 2144 Barksdale in Port Charlotte via Airbnb last year, I had contacted them via Airbnb for a rental in February 2016. I was told by Suzanne that I could get a discount (promised to me after the previous stay in return for a positive review in spite of problems like no lock on the front door, a broken dishwasher, broken shower head, etc.) by going off Airbnb and directly through them which I did so in November. After multiple repeated requests for a confirmation and promises by Suzanne that it would be emailed to me, I now (three weeks prior to my trip) been told that the property is rented to someone else since they could not contact me. There is a string of messages between the two of us from November to present and at no time was I told she did not have my email address (although I can verify she did as well as my mailing address). Here comes the kicker: I get a message from Ed, Eddy, Erdal stating that Suzanne is just the booking agent and that he has another available (and more costly) home available for two weeks of my four week Florida stay. My recommendation to everyone is be very wary of Suzanne and Erdal and never follow their advice to take an Airbnb reservation offline.
View full review
Reason of review:
Poor customer service

Preferred solution: Let the company propose a solution

1 comment
Guest

DO NOT RENT ANYTHING FROM HER. SHE IS A SCAM LOOK UP SUZANNE MCCARTHY ON THE CHARLOTTE COUNTY TAX THESE HOMES ARE FULL OF ROACHES SHE WILL TAKE YOUR MONEY THEN COME UP WITH SOME OTHER BS TO GET MORE MONEY SHE ALSO HAS CAMS IN THE HOMES AND SHE WILL NOT RETURN ANY DEPOSIT

Anonymous
map-marker Port Charlotte, Florida

2015 RENTAL AT PUNTA MADRYN

Anns Rentals - 2015 RENTAL AT PUNTA MADRYN
Anns Rentals - 2015 RENTAL AT PUNTA MADRYN - Image 2
Anns Rentals - 2015 RENTAL AT PUNTA MADRYN - Image 3
READ ALL THIS AFTER MY 2015 RENTAL...WOW...SOMEONE DOESN'T LIKE THIS WOMEN what amazes me if you look up the house their is a kitchen and the place is beautiful, the people don't even collect the rent til after you arrive at the home. I have enclosed pictures of the so called no kitchen statement the place was spotless. Also bloggers please note this home was on the internet and it is thru the agency out of Chicago so the many people that are stated are other agencies that it is listed with that do the bookings. Somebody surely is out to have vengeance maybe a neighbor that doesn't want a rental on the street as many people don't in Florida. I would surely rent again and had no issues except good ones. Please look at kitchen photos as it was lovely. Maggy and Phillip Albany NY
View full review
Reason of review:
Good customer service
4 comments
Guest

What exactly is your complaint? And what in the world is the "no kitchen statement"? You make no sense!

Guest

DO NOT RENT FROM THIS ADDRESS OR THESE PEOPLE IF YOU HAVE PLEASE CALL CHARLOTTE COUNTY TAX AND REPORT THE ADDRESS AND SHOW THEM HER FAKE ***

MCCARTHY ROBERT A & SUZANNE

21053 MIDWAY BLVD

PORT CHARLOTTE, FL 33952

MCCARTHY SUZANNE

25257 PUNTA MADRYN AVE PUNTA GORDA, FL 33983

Guest

Woman not women.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-965895

DO NOT RENT ANYTHING FROM HER. SHE IS A SCAM LOOK UP SUZANNE MCCARTHY ON THE CHARLOTTE COUNTY TAX THESE HOMES ARE FULL OF ROACHES SHE WILL TAKE YOUR MONEY THEN COME UP WITH SOME OTHER BS TO GET MORE MONEY SHE ALSO HAS CAMS IN THE HOMES AND SHE WILL NOT RETURN ANY DEPOSIT

View more comments (3)
Anonymous

Great stay at this home 25257 PUNTA MADRYN, PUNTA GORDA 33983

was looking to rent this home for march 2015 and is booked, upon looking for it I found these horrible reviews surely all lies?? the home has a beautiful gourmet granite kitchen with oak cabinets clearly stated in pictures, the host was very nice we didn't pay a dime until we arrived and were checked into the home the couple couldn't do enough for us. we didn't need anything except our few pieces of luggage we brought from new York. I wanted to take the time to leave great feedback as surely whom-ever is writing bad stuff must have done something and now is pissed off, I know that the place was super clean and no smoking was allowed and the couple was very very picky on who resided in the home so maybe the tenants did some bad stuff and now pissed so leaving bad remarks who knows but the home is on a few websites and can easily be found with pictures of all new appliances and a fab granite/oak kitchen the pool was beautiful, sat tv and internet wifi as promised. the neighborhood was super clean also. had a wonderful stay but sad we can't get to book again ross and peggy buffalo new York 11/22/2014
View full review
1 comment
Guest

DO NOT RENT FROM THIS ADDRESS OR THESE PEOPLE IF YOU HAVE PLEASE CALL CHARLOTTE COUNTY TAX AND REPORT THE ADDRESS AND SHOW THEM HER FAKE ***

MCCARTHY ROBERT A & SUZANNE

21053 MIDWAY BLVD

PORT CHARLOTTE, FL 33952

MCCARTHY SUZANNE

25257 PUNTA MADRYN AVE PUNTA GORDA, FL 33983

Anonymous
map-marker Westland, Michigan

Ann Lacathy, Ann's rentals

I secured a vAcation rental from Ann Lacathy (aka Suzanne McCarthy) in Punta Gorda with a $500 deposit. Just before my arrival I found out the property (25255 Punta Madryn) had no kitchen sink, cabinets or countertops plus several county code violations. Needless to say I cancelled and lost my deposit. This woman and her cohorts - Les Graham, Ed Dimir) are a disgrace to the Port Charlotte/Punta Gorda. She gave me incorrect address as not to find the violations and she changed my dates just before arrival. Thank God a friend found out about this house. She is renting other properties so beware!
View full review
40 comments
Guest

MCCARTHY ROBERT A & SUZANNE

21053 MIDWAY BLVD

PORT CHARLOTTE, FL 33952

MCCARTHY SUZANNE

25257 PUNTA MADRYN AVE

PUNTA GORDA, FL 33983 DONT RENT FROM HER YOU WONT GET YOUR MONEY BACK BOTH HOMES HAVE ROACHES AND SHE HAS CAMS IN THE HOME SHE CAN SEE AND HEAR YOU HOMES ARE DIRTY!!

Guest

She is a liar and a thief.

DO NOT RENT FROM Suzane McCarthy. She will steal your money.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1216015

I do agree she needs to be in jail for a long time. Its very sad she makes a living off people from any state and her boyfriend does the same thing with computers he says he fixes them lol what a joke just call charlotte county tax and turn her in you can even look her up on the tax page she only has 2 nasty homes she rents out not fab homes lol by law you can only rent for a full month not weekly or when ever its not listed as a vaca home and she dont pay taxes the right way so turn her in

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1216015

DO NOT RENT FROM THIS ADDRESS OR THESE PEOPLE IF YOU HAVE PLEASE CALL CHARLOTTE COUNTY TAX AND REPORT THE ADDRESS AND SHOW THEM HER FAKE ***

MCCARTHY ROBERT A & SUZANNE

21053 MIDWAY BLVD

PORT CHARLOTTE, FL 33952

MCCARTHY SUZANNE

25257 PUNTA MADRYN AVE PUNTA GORDA, FL 33983

Guest

If you reserve a house and put a security deposit on it and you don't show up or cancel. They have a right to take your security deposit based on Florida law. That's why it's important to read the rental agreement before you stay at any vacation rental.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1155202

Suzan shut up! and your laws lol

Guest

Whoever posted this has some real personals problems. All they want to do is complian about everything.

I looked into all your compliants on here and it seems that's all your good at doing is complaining about anything and everything. You need to grow up.

I don't believe your made up stories. They don't make any sense.

Guest

After reading your compliant I had my guard up and was prepared for the worst. It never turn out to be a disaster like I had in the back of my head.

All I can say is good things about this women you mention in your compliant.

(Never had any issues with her.) Houses were nicely kept and were a reasonable amount of money to stay there compared to a hotel. I got my deposit back in a few weeks.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1154062

You are her. More deceit.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1154062

Liar!

View more comments (39)
Anonymous
map-marker Washington, District Of Columbia

Vacation rentals

My friend rented this property and it just happened to be in my neighborhood. Well, I got word that this woman "Mccarthy" is renting a property in the neighborhood that is not up to code.....and very filthy, bug ridden etc. Address: 25257 Punta Madryn, Punta Gorda....this woman has many aka and is posing as a realitor. Beware...just google the address. She also uses the address 25255 and there is no such address! AGAIN...BEWARE she and others on this address are SCAMMERS. You do not want to rent this property. Check the address out on Charlotte County Web site or Charlotte county Code enforcement...it is under investigation!
View full review
3 comments
Guest

SO FALSE,,,,CHECKED THE COUNTY AND NOTHING IS WRONG WITH THE PROPERTY OR PERSON YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT THEIR WAS A WARRANT FOR THE SAME PERSON UP IN SARASOTA RENTING FORECLOSED HOMES....I THINK SOMEONE HAS THE WRONG PERSON/NAME

check this out

http://florida.arrests.org/Arrests/Susan_Mccarthy_1242****/

Guest

Well this is where she lives

10144 LONG BEACH ST

PORT CHARLOTTE, FL 33981

this is here scam/bug homes

MCCARTHY ROBERT A & SUZANNE

21053 MIDWAY BLVD PORT CHARLOTTE, FL 33952 MCCARTHY SUZANNE 25257 PUNTA MADRYN AVE PUNTA GORDA, FL 33983 SHE HANGS ON CL

Guest

I just read all the feed-back and the only two complaints are from the friend and the renter?? SO surely the positive feed-back is telling the truth, as stated i have rented 3 times and never had an issue, spotless and NEVER paid a dime until i arrived to the home and keys were left for me to enter on my own until the person arrived to collect the rent.

Stop wasting feed-back on good people you idiots

View more comments (2)

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article