Karen F Gax
map-marker Detroit, Michigan

I would never order from them again

My wife wanted to send a gift to my sister in Tennessee. She order American Coney Island gift 2 to 3 weeks prior to xmas.

They haven't sent them out until the 7 of January. We will never order them again.Lame!

View full review
Reason of review:
Problem with delivery

Preferred solution: Full refund

map-marker Brooklyn, New York

Too hard to digest

Mike Coney is a spicy coney. I ate three of them.They tasted good but I had a stomachache for three days after.

It isn't enough for a coney restaurant to have food that tastes good-- the customer has to be able to enjoy it after it goes down the hatch.

I don't know if Mike Coney buys his coney dogs at the distributor or if he makes his own but he has to pay more attention to the ingredients he puts into his dogs. They taste good and they are crispy to *** but you can keep tasting them for days.

View full review

go seattle!!!


Can't wait for Super Bowl


love the mike coney dogs


this is ***, I love mike coney dogs....nothing like them on the planet


Could the problem be that you ate too many of them at one time?

View more comments (4)

Not Good For Vegetarians

stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full

As a vegetarian, I was expecting a lot more choices. How can a fine dining establishment like American Coney Island Hot Dog stay in business without vegetarian or vegan choices?

I would suggest that they add a tofu or bean curd dog to the menu. While these items may appear disgusting at first due to horrible taste and mealy consistency, with decades of practice forcing them past your nose and taste buds, you could learn to "tolerate" them as I have.

I am certain that if American Coney Island adds more choices for those who like their hot dogs without any actual meat, their sales would skyrocket.

View full review
  • Meat in dogs
Reason of review:
Poor customer service
1 comment

need to find a veggie steak!

Pissed off!

Go Patriots!!!

Aiken Mil
map-marker Pompton Plains, New Jersey


stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full

Mike Coney the inventor of the Coney Island Hot Dog should have stayed in the hamburger business. Okay, so i read this article online about Mike Coney and the his great hot dogs and all the great toppings so my wife and i, big hot dog fans, decided to build a Mike Coney Dog. DON'T EVER DO THIS:

1 Hot Dog Bun

1 100% Pork Dog - deep fried in oil

2 tablespoons of Chile -

4 slices of onions - fried

4 french fried potatoes

1 jalapeno pepper

1 squirt of mustard

1 squirt of ketchup

1 squirt of mayo

I ate two of these Mike Coney monsters and an hour later not even 3 alkaseltzers helped. Bottom line: be careful what recipes you try on line. And Mike Coney who died young, probably from eating one of his concoctions, may he rest in peace.

View full review
  • Idea of the mike coney dog
  • Stomach ache the dog gave me
Reason of review:
Not as described/ advertised

Preferred solution: They should take down Mike Coney website


can't believe the pats pulled it out

we had coney dogs all day


Mike Coney Dog, forget about it. If you want a real Hot Dog the only place to go is in Passaic NJ - It's called Rutz Hut and had been around for a hundred. Order, and Hot Dog shows up in less than 2 minutes.

Deep fried in oil these Thumann dogs dont need no toppings, just mustard and bun.


Can you believe a weekend without a mike coney dog


not feeling good today after a day with Mike Coney dogs and beer


eating a giant mike coney during the ravens game - come on!!!!

I am pissed at the birds - no offense


I just had a coney dog, ouch do I not feel good,

I must have a food allergy because I normally don't get kind of result from a mike coney


I like the mike coney dogs, great at a ball game or after a night of partying

Go mike coney


got to love a good coney dog


Forget about the Mike Coney Coney Island Hot Dog. There is no better dog than you will find at Rutz Hut in Passaic, NJ


This whole thing is a Mike Coney Scam - Probably was never a hot dog named the coney dog. I should know i eat Nathan's dogs by the dozen.

View more comments (16)

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article