• show-popup
  • Signup
Follow us:
 
Shares 0

Hearing Aids - HEARING AIDS-COSTCO Vs MIRACLE EAR Vs BELTONE Vs SURF CITY -COMMODITY Vs EXPERIENCE

  • by   Feb 09, 2008
  • Review #: 112796
CompanyHearing Aids
Location Orange, California
Category Eye and Ear Care
Views7895
 

Mr.David Brooks,the very popular Journalist for the New York Times, and the closest to Conservative Thinking you will find in that Newspaper, wrote on yesterday's OP-ED page in "Questions for Dr.Retail:Listen,the essential competiktion in many consumer sectors is between commodity providers and experience providers,the companies that just deliver product and the companies that deliver a sensation,too".

As I read that, I couldn't help but apply that thinking to the retail Hearing Aid Business.

COSTCO is strictly a Commodity Provider and that especially applys to the way they sell and fit Hearing Aids.

Their Hearing Aid Facility, is the largest ready-made Sound Proof Room produced.

It is located within, what could be classified as a Warehouse with steel racks.

Within that Box, there is an Audiometer.

They administer a Basic Hearing Test, and then they take the order for a set of hearing aids, at the choice of the Customer.

Their Dispensers are Licensed Order Takers or Clerks, or to be kind, as everyone in Retail is now called: Associates.

They are the only State Licensed COSTCO Employees in the Warehouse.

The only reason ANYONE buys HEARING AIDS from them is because of PRICE.

I think the only reason anybody buys anything from COSTCO is because of PRICE.

THEY ARE A PERFECT,COMPLETE,AND TOTAL EXAMPLE OF A COMMODITY PROVIDER.

Mr. Brooks writes about the EXPERIENCE PROVIDER.

At an EXPERIENCE PROVIDER, you sustain an EXPERIENCE in addition to the COMMODITY.

As an example he uses Safeway compared to Whole Foods, the PC compared to the Mac, Holiday Inns compared to W Hotels, Walgreens compared to The Body Shop.

I supposed he could have included SEARS,TARGET,K-MART,WALMART, compared to Bloomingdales,Nordstroms,etc.

Some Providers in the Retail Hearing Aid Business grasp and exploit the "Experience" theory.

Some try to capture the

"MEDICAL" IMAGE.

Some providers even wear WHITE COATS usually worn and associated with MEDICAL DOCTORS.

Such ploys are deliberate and they are effective.

It has been my experience and observation over the past 25 years in the Hearing Aid Industry, that there is no doubt that IMAGE is very important.

Just as People prefer to Dine in nice surroundings, they also prefer any type of SERVICES, in nice,clean,facilities.

But I believe, the most important considerations in the Retail Hearing Aid Business, is Honesty,Integrity,Dedication,Compassion,Empathy,Fairness,Experience,Dedication,Attitude,Sincerity, Knowledge,Understanding,and Communication Skills.

All Virtues in how One Human treats and respects another Human Being.

But each Person makes that Decision on his own.

In the COSTCO example, as far as Hearing Aids are concerned, it is even more pronounced because of PRICE DIFFERENTIAL.

There is no other COMMODITY or PRODUCT or SERVICE, they OFFER and PROVIDE, that is so far or more advantageous, than in the HEARING AID COMMODITY, because of the PRICING BY MOST COSTCO COMPETITORS?.

While Independent,Groups,Medical Doctors, and other PROVIDERS, continue to MARK-UP THE COST OF HEARING AIDS 3 OR 4 TIMES, RESULTING IN RETAIL PRICES OF $3,000 OR $4,000 OR $5,000 OR $6,000 EACH, COSTCO BUYS HEARING AIDS FOR $300 EACH AND SELLS THEM FOR $1700 EACH, AND LOOKS LIKE A HERO,EVEN THOUGH THEIR PROFIT MARGIN IN THE SALE OF HEARING AIDS IS AS MUCH AS 20 TIMES HIGHER THAN ANY OTHER PRODUCTS OR COMMODITIES THEY SELL/.


At least they offer an alternative to the outlandish prices that most other HEARING AID PROVIDERS OFFER;.

As I have said before, all COSTCO OFFERS IS PRICE!.

THEY KNOW IT, AND THEY ACT AS IF THEY ARE THE ONLY GAME IN TOWN,.

AND IN MOST CASES THEY ARE RIGHT..

If their Hearing Aid Provider Competitors had any Brains, they would price the few Hearing Aids Brands, and Models, that
COSTCO offers, at the same price, and they could take COSTCO out of the Hearing Aid Business".

But they aren't that BRIGHT,.

Alsip Magistrate 2f728f8

 
 
Keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject.
Personal attacks will be deleted.
No Links or Scripts.
Hide comments (96) 
Showing 20 of 96 comments
seavoyager seavoyager
May 05  from San Ramon, California
Where is the Costco vs Miracle Ear vs Beltone vs etc ??? Your article was basically about Costco. I was looking for the cmparison you advertised in your title. Misleading and waste of my time.
Reply
catchow catchow
Mar 14  from Los Angeles, California
I have had my S0nix aids since 2007. They were expensive (for me),but helpful. The provider was helpful each time I went back, tune them,test my hearing, & so on. But I plan to go to Costco soon. Their prices are better than elsewhere, & give service as well, later, as needed.
Reply
elijahlovejoy elijahlovejoy
Feb 22  from Seattle, Washington
I do not agree, Alsip. Have been to four regular audis, and 4 costcos. The service has been more professional at the Costcos. By far. They are trying to help HOH people. The regular audi's I've happened to see are so hungry for $ that they end up not being helpful.

I hope and believe there are better audiologists / fitters outside Costco. But I have not been lucky enough to find one in the Seattle area.

Thanks for your comments, though, Judge. They add to the mix in a very useul way.
Reply
deafness deafness
Feb 21 
if you cant afford those $5-6000+ hearing aids like me go check out your local university for an audiology department. a whole lot of them have clinics where you can get full diagnostics by students overseen by licensed doctors along with the latest in technology hearing aids for less than half the price of the local hospital networks audiologist or retail chain like beltone... i paid less than $2000 for my resound aids that were nearly $6000 at the local chain
Reply
Uncle Uncle
Jan 30  from Greenville, South Carolina
I have worn aids for 5 years+. First were analog (web purchase), second were Nu-Ear Rhapsody by a private provider (white coat type operation), third are Costco ReSound units. The Nu-Ear units have required several repairs and during my last visit to the provider I got the sales pitch (again) to replace them. Price was $5400 with a significant (phony) discount. Went to Costco and was tested, aid type suggested, allowed to test it in store and outside. Test was better than that previously given at the private provider. The Costco aids have all the same features as the Nu-Ear units at less than 50% of the cost. Costco associate was very knowledgeable and not pushy. I have purchased the aids and am very satisfied with the performance and Costco's service. Costco's battery price is less than on-line prices and much less than the private provider's battery club.
Reply
elijah lovejoy, ph.d  retired elijah lovejoy, ph.d retired
Sep 22, 2012 
beltone aids are made by Resound. Costco sells the Resound FORZA. for a much better price.

I'm a great fan of Costco, helping the world to hear.
Reply
Brad Brad
Sep 06, 2012 
I've been to Costco and a local, high-advertiser audiologist to test their wares. They are all too expensive for me so I'm using Songbirds which seems to meet most of my needs. They are about $400 each and have lasted almost 3 years so far. I'm not sure how much better I could hear with more expensive ones but the incremental cost would be outrageous I'm sure.
Reply
mp mp
Aug 25, 2012 
Make sure you really check with a Costco dispenser or audiologist before believing some of these other comments. Some of the negative stuff I am reading is definitely not true. Yes they are busy but for those who want to save 2 to 3K and still get 90 day trial plus 2-3 year warranty it is worth the wait.
Reply
Maria Maria
Aug 17, 2012 
I have a widex cic in one ear. Went to the audiologist to get one for the other ear. $3000. Went to Costco. He is telling me I need to get a receiver in the ear. Less $. But I want 2 cic. I feel like he is pushing a product
Reply
Paul Paul
Feb 12  from Baltimore, Maryland
A RIC is a far superior sounding product than a CIC
Reply
Dustmop Dustmop
Aug 06, 2012 
I have been using COSTCO hearing aids for over twenty years and recommend them to friends on a regular basis. They are not for those who can afford much more expensive and better ones, but for those of us on fixed incomes and still want to be able to hear, they are a great alternative. I started with one in my worst ear and they helped me do that for many years, until I finally bought one for the other ear. My aids have lasted about five years, and if they went out or needed adjustment I went back. The techs were always helpful. At times I had to send them in for a $95 repair that was guaranteed for a year. They used to offer a free replacement guarantee on new aids for the first year, but no longer give that perk. Anyway, one of my current aids needs replacing - it's been six years and I am booking an appointment with COSTCO.
Reply
Profesional Audiologist Profesional Audiologist
Aug 01, 2012 
I am not going to knock Costco for their prices because they are enticing. However, you should all know that you can not purchase the low level of hearing aids that Costco offers at an Audiologist office because Costco offers outdated technology that is lower than any level of technology even provided to the Audiologists. Ironically the price that Costco charges for the level of technology provided is too high...much higher than an Audiologist would charge for the same level of technology. You will also not be receiving level of care and service, nor the expertise to diagnose or treat medical conditions at Costco. If you really care about maximizing your hearing without risking causing further damage to your ears or hearing, and you want to purchase appropriate technology that maximizes your investment without breaking you budget, you should seek out a local licensed and certified Audiologist.
Reply
Anonymous Anonymous
Jan 19  from Los Angeles, California
Now, you don't suppose this comment was just a little sour grapish?
Reply
Really? Really?
Feb 17 
How would you know what Costco sells, their protocal and service? There are as many crappy audiologists in the field as there is dispensers, just as there is many great audiologists and dispensers. Many of the latter work at Costco.
Reply
elijahlovejoy elijahlovejoy
Feb 22  from Seattle, Washington
professional audiologist is either a pirate or misinformed. The aids sold at Costco are FIRST RATE. They sometimes offer "best" and "better" tech levels (called 9 and 7). If you buy the 9, you get a better aid than most people get from regular audis / regular retail.

Professional Audis are losing lots of customers, not surprising.

They are hurting. Not surprising.

This clouds their vision, or prompts them to say things which are ... ummm ... not very true.

I know.

Elijah Lovejoy, Ph.D.
retired from U.C. Santa Barbara, where I taught research methods and statistics for 30 years.

If you don't care about value for money, go wherever you like. Some people, I'm sure, get very fine service from professional audiologists. But they pay through the nose, and may think they're dealing with a Used Car Salesman.

caveat emptor (let the buyer beware).

Long Live Costco!

elijah
Reply
ellsbel ellsbel
Jul 22, 2012 
Funny to me that this article states that hearing aid dispensers are the only State licensed employees working for Costco. Hmm...lets see,Pharmacy Technicians are state licensed (some also nationally certified) and in the optical department, eye glass dispensers are also state licensed. I agree with all of the wonderful comments on their hearing aid departments at Costco. Just wanted to clear up that one little misstated fact...that's all.
Reply
Jennifer Jennifer
Jul 21, 2012 
My insurance covers hearing aids if you are over 65 or under 19. I'm 45 so I guess if I don't have the $2,000+ that audiologists charge for a basic unit I am supposed to suck it up and say "What?" 100 times a day. Thank you CostCo for offering a great product for half the price. It is the only option for many of us, but even if there were others the 'associates' there are wonderful to work with!
Reply
SPR SPR
Jul 05, 2012 
I have worn hearing aids my ENTIRE life. I am now 40. I have had the costco aids, miracle ear, and even widex. I currently have a set of Beltone True 17 behind the ear hearing aids. I LOVE them! Yes, they cost me 5000.00 BUT they are such good quality that I am not going to have to replace them for at LEAST 5 years....your costco aids, 3 MAX! I don't CARE what you think, they are volume sold junk! Beltone has a 3 year warranty AND they gave me free batteries for 3 years! I have NEVER been treated the way they do. I had to go in once a week for a month until the aids were adjusted to JUST how I like them. I also got WIRELESS ACCSESSORIES! Bluetooth for my cell phone, a wireless hook up for my tv...my hearing aids are the headphones and I can watch tv muted and I am the only one that can hear it! The cell phone calls come into my hearing aids...STEREO. I have NO issues with forking over that kind of money if it's going to make my life BETTER! Beltone's TRUE line is the BEST! He gave me the option of a lesser TRUE for less money but I wanted the top of the line because no matter the cost, my quality of LIFE is important to me. Financed...100.00 bucks a month...stop eating out everyday and get to a Beltone, you can thank me later!
Reply
SPR is either a pirate, or an SPR is either a pirate, or an
Feb 22  from Seattle, Washington
SPR is simply wrong.

Go to Costco, buy a Resound. Same is sold by Beltone for twice the price. Beltone does NOT give a 90 day trial at no charge.

caveat emptor

elijah lovejoy, ph.d
Reply
Cheap??? Cheap???
Jun 29, 2012 
Think you hearing aid snobs, cheap hearing aids may be the only alternative for many. It is more likely that a low price means hearing or not hearing if you do not have an extra $5000-8000 in your right pocket- oops no it's in my left pocket, sorry....its in my left pocket.
Reply

Read next Hearing Aids complaint

HEARING AIDS-PATIENCE OF A...

A long time Client, a lovely very independent Widow,at age 95 is as astute and sharp as any 65 year...

Select Reason




 
Send Report Cancel

Thank you!

We will review your report
You were reading a complaint about Hearing Aids.
Filing a new complaint about

Report a bug

 
Help us help you!
We are trying to be better!

We need your email address to contact you if we need more bug information. Please provide a valid email address. We do not add this email address to any kind of mailing list or post it on the web

A one-line description of the bug

What were you trying to accomplish and what is the result?

Any errors or messages you may have received

Cancel
 
Report a bug

Thank you!

We will review your report